sun 19/11/2017

Peaky Blinders, BBC Two | reviews, news & interviews

Peaky Blinders, BBC Two

Peaky Blinders, BBC Two

Guns, gangs, anarchy and dodgy accents in post-World War One Birmingham

Hubris and nemesis? Tommy Shelby (Cillian Murphy, left) meets the ruthless Inspector Campbell (Sam Neill)

Much hype has been whipped up around this tale of a gang of thuggish, racketeering bookies in Birmingham just after World War One. It's a pretty good cast, with Helen McCrory's Aunt Polly laying down the law within the criminal Shelby family, Cillian Murphy playing her ambitious nephew Tommy and Sam Neill as sinister Belfast copper Inspector Campbell. But this opener still felt a little wobbly on its feet.

A lot of it was down to the accents, which can be slippery little devils to get right (we know how easily attempts at Welsh can end up detouring to Mumbai). Since this is Birmingham, everyone has been speed-coached into sticking lots of oys and ows and eeews into every sentence, like Harry Enfield's permatanned Black Country flash-harry who is considerablay richer than yow. In a long introductory tracking shot, as Tommy rode through his lowlife manor on horseback casting a critical eye over the handiwork of the vintage props department, he was hailed by a couple of tame coppers with a cheery "morning, mistur Shelbu-yee!" On the other hand, Paul Anderson's Arthur Shelby sounds as if he hails from Wolverhampton-on-Mersey, while McCrory's "loying arownd" hinted at a mysterious West Country provenance.

All of this had the effect of applying a subtle patina of farce to the proceedings, which of course wasn't the idea at all. Indeed, Peaky Blinders creator Steven Knight is to be commended for (if nothing else) the breadth of his ambitions. His traumatised post-war milieu takes in industrial unrest and Communist agitators in the workplace, the battle against Fenians and the IRA in Northern Ireland and a general air of incipient social breakdown. Gang warfare between the Peakies and Billy Kimber's mob is also on the agenda for future episodes (Iddo Goldberg as Communist recruiter Freddie Thorne, pictured above).

The big plot idea driving the piece is the mistaken theft of a huge cache of guns and ammunition from Birmingham's BSA factory (Tommy's boys were supposed to nick some motorcycles but they grabbed the wrong crates), which has terrified the authorities so much that they've sent in ferocious super-cop Campbell to get the weapons back using any methods that work. Although Campbell has been warned, by a relatively youthful Winston Churchill (Andy Nyman), then Secretary of State for War, not to leave bodies floating ostentatiously in the Birmingham canals. 

Neill brings an appropriate ominous bulk to Campbell, introducing himself to his new clientele by hauling Arthur Shelby out of the arms of a brace of hookers in the local cinema and treating him to a heavy-duty beating, but he has to cope with the special burden of speaking Ulster-ese. At least it offers a diversion from bogus Brummie, but it can take a moment to work out that "vushus" is vicious and "tham" is them.

Will it fly? Only one way to find out, but I'd guess that Peaky Blinders might find itself overwhelmed by a tide of historical baggage washing away any fine detail in the characterisations. And those accents have serious millstone potential.

Inspector Campbell has been warned by Winston Churchill, Secretary of State for War, not to leave bodies floating ostentatiously in the Birmingham canals

rating

Editor Rating: 
3
Average: 3 (1 vote)

Share this article

Comments

Stagey and mannered, from the sets to the dialogue, I could only stand about 20 minutes of it. But then I thought the same about 'Boardwalk Empire'. And WTF was going on with that soundtrack? Didn't exactly aid suspension of disbelief. All a bit of a shame, because lurking beneath the artifice there seemed to be a damn good story trying to get out. I suspect that critics love these shows because they provide plenty to write about. Coherent, compelling, drama it wasn't...

Mannered is right. It looked like an over-extended commercial (hovis?) with actors fighting with a script that hit more wrong notes than a scrap metal gamelan. It seemed to be trying to get away from British social realism towards a mythic feel midway between boardwalk empire and gangs of new York with a bit of Brecht thrown in. I found it excruciating. 20 mins was far too long.

I don't think this is a social realist piece so the points over the accents are probably lost on most people. To have given up after 20 minutes meant you missed Sam Neill eating the scenary with a performance that'll get him pints life down the Shankill. Definitely worth watching.

Finding fault with accents from a time we don't know of is churlish. For me the fantastic acting, dialogue, story-lines, the amazing cinemagraphic sets & use of the music all adds up to something so wonderful, rare & fabulously entertaining. Fair enough not to like it, but the wibbling about accents is a red-herring.

Add comment

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 10,000 pieces, we're asking for £3.95 per month or £30 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take an annual subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters