Was such an enduring legacy ever so quickly consummated? With just two films - Howard Hawks’s To Have and Have Not and The Big Sleep, both showing as part of HOME Manchester’s Bogart and Bacall season - the most potent movie romance of the 20th century was permanently etched into the public imagination.
The origin story is as well-worn as a bible tale. Hawks’s wife, Nancy "Slim" Keith, a noted beauty, wit and fashion maven, spots Lauren Bacall on the cover of Harper’s Bazaar magazine. Nancy shows Howard the cover; Howard’s antennae twitch; soon Bacall is on a train from New York to LA. Howard and Nancy coach Bacall in matters of style and bearing, then Hawks takes a chance by casting her in her first film against Humphrey Bogart. Bacall proves a hit in more ways than Hawks envisaged.
Watching these two classics back-to-back today, you can almost track the screen chemistry intensifying in real time. It begins with Bacall asking the loaded question, “Anybody got a match?” in To Have and Have Not, and ends with two pointedly post-coital cigarettes nestled side-by-side in an ashtray at the close of The Big Sleep.
In between, Hawks proves this theory that all a great film requires is a sequence of great scenes, like pearls strung on a thread. Give the audience a good time, and they won’t care about fripperies such as plot, or cohesion. (The “confusing” narrative of The Big Sleep, by the way, with its supposedly “unsolved murder”, has been vastly overplayed.)
Hawks had very particular ideas about the feminine ideal. The “Hawksian woman” had to be sultry, insolent, tough-minded, and independent (of everything except Howard Hawks). Hawks was forever on the lookout for young actresses he could play Svengali to. And here Bacall was: a face like Helen of Troy after a glow-up; slick and feline, 19 years old; cheekbones you chop down a Jacaranda tree with. He must have felt like the cat who got the keys to the creamery. All of this crumbled to ashes when Bacall and Bogart fell in love. But that didn’t prevent some tributaries from the Hawkses’ relationship flowing into the rich, complex meld of fantasy and reality that became the Bogart and Bacall legend.
In To Have and Have Not, Bogart and Bacall are avatars for Hawks and Nancy. They call each other “Steve” and “Slim”, the Hawkses’ nicknames for one another. Hawks claimed it was Slim’s insolent, coquettish character that Bogart fell in love with, so Bacall “had to keep playing it the rest of her life”. Much of that assertion was exaggeration squeezed from sour grapes, but not all of it. Bogie and Bacall retained some aspects of Howard and Nancy; they even continued calling each other Steve and Slim in real life.
Knowing this adds an extra frisson to their scenes. In To Have and Have Not’s most famous sequence, Bacall loses patience with Bogart’s passivity, and tells him that if he wants her all he has to do is to whistle: “You know how to whistle, don’t you Steve? You just put your lips together and blow.” That ripe little cherry bomb of innuendo was dreamt up by Slim Hawks. Originally intended for use only in rehearsal, Bacall put the line across so well that Hawks added it to the script.
Bacall’s character in To Have and Have Not mirrors the actress’s status at the time. She’s low on the totem pole: an indigent single woman with no visible means of support beyond stealing wallets from lecherous men. By proving herself according to the Hawksian ideal - failing to flinch when slapped, or to faint at the sight of blood; demonstrating her gift for barbed repartee - she achieves parity. This kudos also accrues to Bacall, allowing her to make her famous, slinky exit: wiggling out of the film and into Hollywood aristocracy.
The dynamic in The Big Sleep is drastically different. As Marlowe, Bogart is a supplicant in millionaire General Sternwood’s mansion, and Bacall, as the imperious Vivian Sternwood, openly relishes her superior position. Arch and bitingly sarcastic, Vivian comes across like one of the orchids from the General’s greenhouse - complete with “the rotten sweetness of corruption”.
Summoning Marlowe into her glitzy boudoir, she condescendingly mocks his appearance and profession. When he talks back, she tells him she doesn’t like his manners, to which Bogart responds with one of his great staccato fusillades of dialogue:
Marlowe: “I'm not crazy about yours. I didn't ask to see you. I don't mind if you don't like my manners. They're pretty bad, I grieve over them on long winter evenings, and I don't mind your ritzing me, or drinking your lunch out of a bottle, but don't waste your time trying to cross-examine me.”
Vivian: “People don’t talk to me like that!”
Marlowe: “Ooooooh.”
Everybody enjoyed themselves making To Have and Have Not, and it comes across on the screen. The opposite was true of The Big Sleep set. Hawks was embittered with Bacall and had fallen out with Bogart, who wasn’t at leisure to enjoy Bacall because he was racked with guilt over leaving his third wife, Mayo Methot. Mayo was a spitfire, and Bogie actively enjoyed their drunken brawls. According to Bogart’s friend Joe Hyams, Hawks once asked Bogart if he could achieve an erection without fighting with Mayo first, to which the actor eventually concluded that no, he probably couldn’t.
We can't take our eyes of Bacall, and neither can Bogart. The critic Imogen Sara Smith perceptively notes how, in To Have and Have Not, Bogie “gives a definitive performance as an observer; what he chiefly observes is Lauren Bacall’s definitive performance as a performer, whose visible effort only enhances the effect.” Bogart goes out of his way to give Bacall space, holding back and letting her run with it, a twinkle of proud amusement in his eyes.
In The Big Sleep, they both play observer and performer. When they prank call the police station, taking turns with the telephone as they wind the policeman up into a rage, it’s the apotheosis of performing and observing: egging each other on and savouring the results. There’s an easy, in-joke intimacy between them now.
The scene plays like a mating ritual, a temporary sublimation of sexual desire. Once again the line between fantasy and reality is being vigorously smudged. Observing Bacall evasively fidgeting and kneading the knee of her skirt, Bogart tells her to “Go ahead and scratch”. “As so often with Hawks”, David Thomson says, “tiny gestures can loom like Zeppelins of subtext”.
There’s no need for subtext with Martha Vickers, but she loomed dangerously large in her supporting role as Vivian’s murderous, nymphomaniac, borderline psychotic younger sister Carmen. Her exchanges with Bogart are hilarious:
Marlowe: “How’d you get in here?”
Carmen: “I bet you can’t guess.”
Marlowe: “I’ll bet I can. You came in through the keyhole, like Peter Pan.”
Carmen: “Who’s he?”
Marlowe: “A guy I used to know around the pool room.”
Not everybody was laughing. Vickers’s unmistakable chemistry with Bogart threatened to muddy the waters. Big Sleep author Raymond Chandler reckoned Vickers “blew Bacall completely away”. He wasn’t the only one Carmen made hot under the collar: Hawks resented being cock-blocked by Bogart, but his professionalism (not to mention his gambling debts) compelled him to make as good a film as he possibly could; he also consoled himself by having a brief fling with Vickers.
It’s easy to see why Bacall’s powerful agent, Charles Feldman, pushed for her to have more scenes of an “insolent and provocative nature”. Even that penny-pinching ghoul Jack Warner agreed, approving the reshooting of some scenes and addition of others, to give Bacall (i.e. their investment) a boost.
Vickers is blisteringly sexy. She slides through her scenes like an ice cream scoop. Still, Lauren Bacall has an almost otherworldly beauty. She’s at her most seductive in the scene in Marlowe’s car, when he pulls over to challenge her about exactly what happened at Eddie Mars’s casino. (Mars is the poison spider at the centre of The Big Sleep’s convoluted web of plot, but Hawks didn’t care about that and neither do we.)
Slumped in the seat of the tiny car, Bacall is so glamorous it’s like that fur coat she’s swaddled in is wearing her. The shine in her wide-set eyes matched by the gleam on her sumptuous lower lip, she's so glossy she calls to mind F Scott Fitzgerald’s description of a girl who looks as though “if you touched her she'd smear."
The erotic tension reaches a crescendo in the greatest of the added scenes, the one with the infamous, censor-baiting “horse racing” dialogue:
“I like to see if they’re front-runners or come from behind.”
“I don’t know how far you can go.”
“A lot depends on who’s in the saddle.”
Ultimately, what these films are really “about” is two movie stars falling in love. By the time this scene was filmed, Bogart and Bacall were married. Fantasy and reality were fully fused. Their marriage became a nodal point in the Hollywood mythos.
The dialogue is sensational, but watch Bogart’s subtle physical movements, his bits of business, play with props, and how expressively he acts with his eyes. He does indulge in some enjoyably broad gestures - he rubs his earlobe like it’s Aladdin's lamp - but it’s the finer grain that really shines. What appears natural or casual is actually deliberate, and carefully calibrated. As Truman Capote observed: “In the end, Bogart really was an artist. And a very selective one. All the gestures and expressions were pruned down and pruned down.”
Maybe because he’s so much fun to watch, has such astonishing charisma, Bogart doesn’t quite get the level of recognition he should as an artist. Behind all the cult iconography, he was a great technical actor. (He disdained the Method as "the scratch your ass and mumble school of acting”.) His iconic performance in The Big Sleep is one of his most nuanced and richly layered. Having Lauren Bacall to spark off doesn’t hurt, either.
David Thomson called To Have and Have Not “an airy fantasy”, which is fair. The Big Sleep is harder to categorise. Wendy Haslem suggested “hardboiled romance”; that’s good, but what about the comedy? It’s an acerbically funny film. Some of the sardonic one-liners are as indelible as anything in cinema.
Casablanca, said Umberto Eco, “isn’t one movie. It is movies”. Same goes for To Have and Have Not (which is really a remix of Casablanca), and The Big Sleep. You could write a book about the meta of it all. The Big Sleep repeatedly references To Have and Have Not. It also quotes itself quoting Hollywood tropes: “Whaddya want me to do, count three like in the movies?”, Eddie Mars’s henchman Canino jokes before murdering someone; later Marlowe quotes that same line at Mars.
Form is content. The characters don’t make wisecracks and exhibit Olympic level sang-froid en route to some greater objective: how you carry yourself is the objective. As Imogen Sara Smith points out, when Eddie (Walter Brennan) asks “Was you ever bit by a dead bee?”, it’s a test. What he’s asking is: Are you one of us? Are you cool? Can you take a joke? Or are you just a po-faced, self-regarding prig?
Our identification with Bogart isn’t an intellectual thing. It’s something we feel. He was, as Alistair Cooke had it, a man “with a tough shell and a fine core”. A stoic capable of shrugging off life’s darkest aspects with gallows humour. “I stick my neck out for nobody,” he said, but we knew he was lying. He stuck it out repeatedly in real life. He risked his career to stand up to the HUAC fascists, and you better believe he would be shouting “Free Palestine” from the rooftops if he were with us today. He evokes Thomas Pynchon’s maxim: “Love with your mouth shut, help without breaking your ass or publicizing it: keep cool, but care.”
Bogie and Bacall made just four films together, of which Hawks’s two are by far the best. These films don’t age. They don’t wear out. No couple ever lit up Hollywood quite as brightly as Bogie and Bacall. They set the screen on fire. By the miracle of technology, they aren’t ghosts of the past today. They’re there for us any time we need them. All we have to do is whistle. You know how to whistle, don’t you?