Help keep arts journalism alive.

We’re rebuilding theartsdesk to secure it as a bastion of real culture writing in the face of algorithmic recommendations and AI slop. Your participation is absolutely vital to this - subscribe today and be part of this movement.

SUBSCRIBE TODAY 

La Bataille de Gaulle review - pitch-perfect portrait of a maverick hero

Simon Abkarian amazes as director Antonin Baudry moves from occupation to liberation

share this article

Simon Russell Beale as Churchill and Simon Abkarian as De Gaulle

Many epic biopics make a messy spread of their protagonist's life (the overrated Oppenheimer is a prime example). Not this one. Though De Gaulle's title in France means it could have spanned its extraordinary hero's exploits in both World Wars, director Antonin Baudry and his co-writer (and partner) Bérénice Vila plunge us with great cinematic aplomb right at the start of Part One, via Charles Trenet's "Boum!" and the final Polish radio broadcast of 1939, into the Nazi occupation of France the following year and end their second part with De Gaulle and Churchill in Paris at the armistice of 1944. 

If you haven't read A Certain Idea of France: The Life of Charles de Gaulle by Julian Jackson, who collaborated on the film, you'll want to after this. Were the story of how how De Gaulle and his France Libre movement got the whole of the country behind him fiction, you'd hardly believe it. The essence is essentially that of Shakespeare's Henry V - "all things be ready, if our minds be so" - allied to an invincible moral backbone against the Vichyists' easy capitulation. 

Image
Simon Abkarian as De Gaulle

French-Armenian Simon Abkarian's nuanced portrayal of De Gaulle, with some of the best eye acting I've ever seen in a film, is not above suggesting the absurdity in his absolute sense of rightness. He even has a fictional Polish plumber to play Sancho Panza to his Don Quixote, Blazej (played with gentle humour by Karim Leklou). The main foil is the constant watchfulness of Churchill, who gives him his first break only to turn his back at crucial moments. His own quirkiness provides the perfect role for Simon Russell Beale, likewise convincing from the start and never over the top, except where Churchill is. If there are best actor awards going, these two should share it, at least for Part One; the scene where De Gaulle bangs Churchill's table and smashes a porcelain bust of Napoleon would clinch it single-handedly.

Counterpointed storylines in both parts are consummately done. The passionate involvement of young anti-fascist monarchist Fernand Bonnier de La Chapelle, who kicks off the saga, may look like convenient, even sentimental, fiction to those of us unfamiliar with his real-life actions; the consequences of what he does at the end of Part One turn out to be crucial. I won't add a spoiler, since it's a thriller for those not in the know, as are De Gaulle's many comebacks as the proverbial cat with nine lives. 

Image
Florian Lesieur and Anamaria Vartolomei as young resisters

Florian Lesieur is the ardent adolescent to the life, elevating the character as he gives a threatening performance of "Boum!" in front of a hated audience at a Parisian cafe. Fernand is given discreet love interest in fellow resister Livia (Anamaria Vartolomei, also note-perfect), but her trajectory isn't what we expect: instead of being deported to a death camp as a Jew, she represents the resistance in Part Two as she follows leader Jean Moulin, aka "Rex", played by Félix Kysyl, and carries on the struggle after his brutal torture and death in 1943. 

This strand also allows for striking symmetries between the two parts: Livia is twice on a Paris roof with rifle, and the strongly-filmed youth uprising at the Arc de Triomphe in Part One - full marks here to cinematographers Pierre Cottereau and Giora Bejach - is paralleled by the last stand in Paris towards the end of Part Two. The young resisters in Part One were on their own; in 1944 they're saved (possible spoiler!) by De Gaulle's younger reincarnation, saviour of France Libre General Philippe Leclerc. If Russell Beale is less often seen in the second film, Niels Schneider's Leclerc becomes central, and we shed tears for his heroism as we did for De Gaulle in Part One. In the second part, the Americans led by Roosevelt (Campbell Scott) come off poorly until we thank our lucky stars for a crucial decision by Eisenhower (Daniel Betts).

Image
Niels Schneider as General Leclerc

There are two battle scenes, both heart-in-mouth style, telling a tale of victory over seemingly insuperable obstacles, and if they hark back to old war films, so what? In Part One, the 13-day holding-out of the Free French fighters at Bir Hakeim in 1942, allowing the British army to retreat, is thrillingly told; likewise the unlikely survival of Leclerc and many of his troops, wildly outnumbered by the Nazis at Ksar Ghilane. The films make it clear how both these actions boosted De Gaulle's reputation from his zero starting-point. 

They both bear out the original French names for each film: "L'Âge de fer" (The Age of Iron) and "J'écris ton nom" (I Write Your Name), the refrain of Paul Eluard's great poem "Liberté". It's read out here; I wonder how much greater the effect would be if Baudry had used the unaccompanied choral setting in Poulenc's Figure Humaine. The music is just about the only generic element in the films; it's on a level with the pumping tension used for The Traitors, and could have been composed by AI (Volker Bertelmann scored the first film, Théo Cascio the second).

No matter; the work's impact is partly due to its popular packaging, and the story of its slow build from a poor start to viewing by millions in France, is a stirring one: young people made up a sizeable percentage of the audience. One in the eye, surely, for current French collaborators with foreign powers, and if it plays its part in reducing their following. Baudry's work will have done its work. But the fact also remains that it's a triumph of cinematic storytelling prompting total engagement with its main characters. Could there be a post-war sequel?

Abkarian's portrayal of De Gaulle has some of the best eye acting I've ever seen in a film

rating

5

explore topics

share this article

more film

Micro-budget sci-fi double bill from a cult director
A Romanian moralist puts progressive Norway on trial
Documentarist Vincent Munier offers heart stopping moments of joy and excitement
The filming of a propaganda porno parses the nature of acting onscreen and off
Fantastic portrait of a woman assuming the driving seat against the odds
He's back and still pretty cross with the human race
Powerful romance about a young trans woman and her doomed lover
Two more fantastic women, as Sebastian Lelio explores lesbian love in a cold religious climate
John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell are bickering CIA agents, waiting for Allende to fall
Eye-popping East German folktales in gleaming new prints
Alexander Skarsgård and Olivia Colman weaving together a fine romance