Help keep arts journalism alive.

We’re rebuilding theartsdesk to secure it as a bastion of real culture writing in the face of algorithmic recommendations and AI slop. Your participation is absolutely vital to this - subscribe today and be part of this movement.

SUBSCRIBE TODAY 

Primetime review - when journalists create the news

An extremely stylish recreation of the rise and fall of American vigilante TV

share this article

Robert Pattinson as Chris Hansen, shot on the decoy set

There’s an online debate whether director Lance Oppenheimer has traduced the real Chris Hansen with Primetime, a feature film about Hansen’s glory days as an investigative journalist for NBC. Admirers (and lesser imitators) of his technique feel their hero has been misrepresented. But what strikes me as more unsettling is the role of the police. Can I coin a portmanteau word  to describe the genre the TV reporter Chris Hansen, the subject of Primetime, made his own? We’ve had "infotainment" since the 1980s but it  doesn’t convey what NBC’s producers did between 2004-2009.

Instead of waiting for the police to catch suspected paedophiles, Hansen and his team crafted the situation for the authorities. Collaborating with a cohort of civilian vigilantes who called themselves Perverted-Justice, Hansen and his producers would coach young-seeming adult actors to impersonate teenagers chatting online with strangers. The decoy actors would invite older men interested in sex to their house.

The NBC producers had filled the decoy’s home with hidden cameras and microphones. The man who had met them online would arrive, keen to hook up with the teen decoy, only to be confronted by Chris Hansen, who would read extracts from the sexually explicit online chat before handing him over to the waiting police outside. NBC’s cameras would be ready but the network would also use footage provided by police cameras (including body-cameras, which were not standard equipment in the 2000s). The police would look good, NBC’s Dateline news show’s ratings would rocket (peaking at seven million in 2006), all without too much effort and money.  How about we call this phenomenon "enforcetainment"? Gripping TV, bad people being put away, cooperative police, potential perpetrators being frightened off – what’s not to love? 

Well, quite a lot actually: one of the show's targets killed himself when he saw the Texan police and Hansen’s cameras outside his own house in November 2006. The police were accused of improperly executing their duties while NBC was criticized for leading police operations at the expense of safety and justice. The network was sued by the sister of the man who killed himself and paid out an undisclosed sum to settle the case. NBC cancelled Hansen’s show (although he is still making similar content online.)  

The story behind Primetime is not unfamiliar to the media: Esquire magazine ran a damning feature in 2007, a documentary came out last year. But what Primetime offers as a film is a mesmerising performance by Robert Pattinson. It’s not an exact waxwork impersonation of Chris Hansen, who judging by the clips online is a far more conventionally smooth TV everyman than Pattinson’s rendering conveys. He plays the journalist as a man haunted by ambition, twitching with jealousy of the main presenter of Dateline whenever he encounters him.  Pattinson dominates the screen, often shot in close-up, it’s a highly mannered enactment of a character the director clearly wants the audience to dislike.  

The film’s look is highly distinctive, distorted close-ups, saturated colour grading pushing images to extremes.  This is not gritty naturalism but a style that signals to the audience in every frame that this is art house cinema. Cinematographer David Bolen used a huge range of camera setups throughout the film. Mini-DV cameras were placed throughout the decoy’s house to recreate the original surveillance technology of the 2006 setup. Meanwhile the main narrative was filmed and developed to give it the look of grainy 16mm film stock.  There's even a sequence using the kind of micro-camera used to perform colonoscopies. The ambition to be in the pantheon of visual innovators alongside  directors like Kubrick, Lynch and Fincher seems clear. 

The artistry and performances are undeniably impressive, the occasional moment of humour very welcome, but an hour and 50 minutes is a long time to spend on a story that doesn’t really develop beyond recreating events. A few less reenactments of the sickening stings and a little more time spent on what led Hansen (a previously award winning investigative journalist) to take this turn, vigilantism per se and the repercussions on policing in America might have given the film more breadth. 

He's a man haunted by ambition, twitching with jealousy

rating

4

explore topics

share this article

more film

Micro-budget sci-fi double bill from a cult director
A Romanian moralist puts progressive Norway on trial
Documentarist Vincent Munier offers heart stopping moments of joy and excitement
The filming of a propaganda porno parses the nature of acting onscreen and off
Fantastic portrait of a woman assuming the driving seat against the odds
He's back and still pretty cross with the human race
Powerful romance about a young trans woman and her doomed lover
Two more fantastic women, as Sebastian Lelio explores lesbian love in a cold religious climate
John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell are bickering CIA agents, waiting for Allende to fall
Eye-popping East German folktales in gleaming new prints
Alexander Skarsgård and Olivia Colman weaving together a fine romance