Aaron Sorkin’s sequel to his The Social Network screenplay is an old-fashioned, stolid response to social media’s wildfire spread and corrosive power. David Fincher directed Mark Zuckerberg’s damning 2010 origin story. Sorkin directs this time, and Jesse Eisenberg also declined to revisit Zuckerberg in his imperial phase. Neither absence fully explains the flatness of this exposé of Facebook’s algorithmic assault on democracy and basic decency.
A film self-consciously chopped into chapters peaks in its prologue, as a white woman escalates a car breakdown attended by two black cops into a rage-bait face-off live-streamed to her far-right followers. For a brief, vivid moment this mimics Facebook’s MO, driving adrenalized engagement and dramatically making us pick sides. Sorkin incidentally flips the script of police shootings of black drivers caught in vital, viral footage. At least the heart of his subject beats here, embodied in raw confrontation.
Sorkin then dramatises an investigation of Facebook by The Wall Street Journal’s Jeff Horwitz (Jeremy Allen White). “Something happened,” the tech-novice intuits of its changed business model. It takes data scientist whistleblower Frances Haugen (Mikey Madison, pictured above left with White) to explain the company’s choice to reward resharing, with its inbuilt favouring of extreme and polarising content. Always inadequate fact-checking is also downgraded. A third strand sees Zuckerberg (Jeremy Strong, pictured below) drive wholly commercial imperatives, which turn the trillion-dollar business he likes to term a civic square into a slum of radicalising misinformation. This is what the real-life Horwitz, Haugen and Sorkin want to tell us. The director can’t, though, find a cinematic means to do so.
By design of Facebook and its ilk, these are lives spent in front of screens. As a last-gasp print newsroom drama, All The President’s Men’s precisely immersive workplace, paranoid sense of consequence, finely drawn characters and star chemistry stay a distant model. The Wall Street Journal’s Frisco office feels fake, and Horwitz’s penchant for Frank Capra films over computers suggests Sorkin’s fusty distance from his subject. It’s no His Girl Friday, either, as his screwball-style patter atypically misfires, with dour male leads further sinking its subpar zing. And this film is all talk.
Strong’s Zuckerberg is tech lord as Sith Lord, balefully swivelling in bulletproof office furniture as Alexandre Desplat’s score pumps up supervillain vibes. This is exactly how Zuckerberg and his peers bestride the world, but they are still flesh and blood. The android update of Eisenberg’s prototype tips Strong’s Method intensity into a character vacuum.
Mikey Madison is a saving grace, as moral conviction warms her mousey Facebook underling’s soul. Sorkin finds reasons to dress her in slinky outfits and a late, desperate hint of romance with Horwitz, but the surely terrifying pressure of her heroic treachery is another lacuna.
The Social Reckoning spans 2019-21, and the Capitol riots’ empty reenactment is the denouement of its roadside start. Sony and Sorkin deserve credit for making this in such a harsh and often craven US media climate. Its journalistic content and protesting intent is, though, fatally late, lacking the frisson of One Battle After Another’s fascist round-ups of migrants just as ICE did the same – that rare sense of a film meeting its moment.
Horwitz’s reporting is seen to shake Facebook. But in 2026, Trump has trampled such dissent. The President and MAGA are unnamed here, and Zuckerberg too crudely indicted.