Help keep arts journalism alive.

We’re rebuilding theartsdesk to secure it as a bastion of real culture writing in the face of algorithmic recommendations and AI slop. Your participation is absolutely vital to this - subscribe today and be part of this movement.

SUBSCRIBE TODAY 

Editors slow down a bit too early with 'Surface, Echo & Sound'

The Midlands rockers lack punch on their latest record

share this article

'It feels like a solo project made at the end of a long successful career'

Following a career defined by evolving through genres, Editors' eighth album shifts their sound from electronic rock straight to almost retired dad musings. Surface, Echo & Sound’s singles are being praised by fans as a return to roots, but as a casual listener, it is hard to find the punchiness or relatability of previous popular tracks anywhere in this album.

A clear love of Eighties music, in all of its most popular forms, is apparent throughout Editors discography. Surface, Echo & Sound merges new wave, folk and classic rock but remains too slow paced and easily digestible to make much of an impact. It feels like a solo project made at the end of a long successful career, full of unfinished and rejected songs, just so they could exist somewhere.

The vocal style, straightforward lyrics, and stripped back approach to the music makes 45-year-old frontman Tom Smith sound far more time-worn than he ought to. "The Rush”, “Real” and “Seriously” are particularly obvious examples of this, the melodies and themes give the illusion of emotional reflection but there are too many awkwardly simple moments that resemble the harmless ponderings of a band out of touch with modern problems.

In keeping with the already released singles, the album remains driven by acoustic rock, but there is variation within that. “Shadow” is a Bon Jovi-style ballad, with theatrical notes held at the end of easy, literal lyrics “it gets heavy down every road, but there’s still a moon and I’m still your shadow”. “Much Love” channels Muse with the bass, synths and drawn out vocals and provides a more exciting moment melodically, and “The Hills We Died Upon” closes the album with a much softer, prettier approach. Fans of this style of music are likely to find comfort in this slight variety, but this won’t be an album I’ll be returning to. 

The melodies and themes give the illusion of emotional reflection

rating

2

share this article

more new music

The biggest concert of the 2026 EFG London Jazz Festival
The jazz saxophonist and hip-hop player explores what it means to be political in the 2020s
The Los Angeles trio offered plenty of catchy pop tunes, but a lack of variety was frustrating
Two very different avant-garde talents conjure a micro-album of dream ballads
Heavy and intense industrial goth-rock from 2011 with remixes & a full live gig soundtrack
The singular singer-songwriter follows her Sandy Denny project with a powerful album of folk ballads
Dance music’s go-to voice turns caustic and candid, and it’s surprisingly relatable
Bono and Co set loose the last of their latest sessions with Jacknife Lee
Industrial trio turn dread inside out for a party at the end of the world
Rising Arizona-via-New York singer with a predictable but solid outing
The East London singer taps into a deep stream of sophisticated UK soul-reggae-jazz interplay