Something extraordinary is going on here. On Michael Kiwanuka’s previous records, he’s worked with producers Danger Mouse (Gnarls Barkley, Gorillaz, Black Keys) and Inflo (SAULT, Cleo Sol). These two are undeniable masters of their craft, but their deep understanding of classic studio technique and gear often cloaked Kiwanuka’s songs in a generalised retro feel. It gave his output a very strong Later With Jools Holland feel.
Not that there’s anything wrong with that per se, and those records did very well for him. But there was something about them that never quite gelled with me – and now I know why. On FUDGE, his fifth album, he mainly recorded and produced himself, and the transformation is major. It’s like he was wearing a costume the whole time, and for the first time is presenting himself no longer in character. It’s quite uncanny.
The first strange thing about it is how the reference points change and proliferate. It’s easy to hear, say, Paul McCartney – Kiwanuka has always been an avowed Beatles lover, and “Across the Sky” here is laced with Macca (plus a little John Martyn, perhaps). There’s definitely quiet storm soul here, too: “Love in My Heart” nods to Terry Callier, Timmy Thomas, maybe Marvin Gaye. However, because the production is clean, quite modern, not ostentatiously analogue, sometimes it sounds quite 1980s and suddenly you’re hearing… is that Edwyn Collins? Morrissey? Terrence Trent D’Arby? Even… Chris Rea? At other times the indie-ness of it might go to... OK Radiohead, that makes sense, but hang on a minute, is that a hint of The House of Love?
But then the really extraordinary thing happens. On repeat listen, those comparisons fade. They’re still there – you can’t hide a Paul McCartney vibe, right? But what’s there far more is Kiwanuka’s writing voice, clearer than ever before, and able to hold all those similarities within it. The cleaner, simpler production – even when the strings are lavish, as they often are, or guitars get fuzzy – allows real uniqueness out, and the tenderness of them shows through more than ever. And ye gods, they are tender. It’s perfect listening as the seasons turn and the world seems harsh, real soft music for hard times, full of a feeling like an intimate conversation that just for once you have time for and can let unfold.
I tried to listen to the album without thinking of the sad fact that between recording and release Kiwanuka suffered a serious stroke and is still undergoing rehabilitation. And though the knowledge does undeniably add an extra intensity to the mournfulness and vulnerability in some of these songs, it’s still possible to lose yourself in them: as an auteur in command of the whole process, he has unlocked something truly special. Here’s hoping for swift continued recovery and – selfishly – more music like this, because it is the best he’s made.
Listen to "Sing":