Niamh O'Sullivan already had a vision of what kind of Carmen she strived to be: "Bizet's whole opera is her living on her own terms and wanting freedom. It's amazing to see a woman not caring about being palatable to others…The main thing about her is that she is also super-intelligent. And that's what I would love to get across more than anything,” Last night she achieved both of these and much more in a colourful, quirky, and fearless production that was so meticulously acted that she deserves “actor” as a suffix to “mezzo-soprano” going forward.
The Prelude flew under Fergus Sheil but lacked bite and was unhelpfully interrupted by applause before the dramatic theme of Carmen as femme fatale. This was soon forgotten as the curtain was raised to reveal designer Gary McCann's stunning set - two giant parallel billboards of identical paintings of a woman's half face with a cigarette between her lips, on both sides of the stage. Straight ahead was a distant backdrop of a beach and palm trees. Scaffolding on the billboards doubled up as sentry points for two soldiers and some labourers. Underneath the left side billboard were the gates of the factory – full length bars like a prison cell.
It was from here that Carmen emerged. The sinister flurry of strings that immediately precede her entrance iss sometimes inaugurated by her chortling. Not so in this production. We see her before we hear a sound. We don't even hear her steps as she leaps like a ballerina out of the cage/gates and onto the centre of the stage. To the surprise of the audience, she is a brunette, contrary to the photo of a blonde O'Sullivan in a red dress that adorns the programme and posters around the foyer (that's how she appeared in the English National Opera revival of Calixto Bieito's production, in which she shone dramatically but didn't quite carry vocally). Perhaps a joint subversion by O'Sullivan-Carmen in cahoots.
Carmen is slightly dowdy in her work apron, offset completely by her coquettish facial expressions – simpers, curled lip, raised eyebrows – not at all forced. This is a woman who knows her effect on men and the micro-expressions that cause it. Her Habanera is commanding, poised, very slightly shouty and not too saccharine or ornamented. Her movements though are sublime. Taking off the apron to reveal a figure-hugging dress, she weaves around soldiers with the lightness of a ghost, each crestfallen like dominoes falling as she passes. She gracefully ascends the scaffolding stairs up to the billboard where she continues the Habanera to the helpless sentries stationed there. Then some extraordinary stagecraft - Carmen rips off a part of the billboard's painting which is actually made of cloth. She wraps it around her like a sash and waves from the scaffold balcony as if a monarch.
The seductive imperiousness is set as she descends the stairs and spots Don José. She looms over him, takes a flower from her hair, raises it up as if to get ready to throw it but doesn't. She drops it on him nonchalantly, letting it fall on him without any active propulsion from her – an omen, perhaps, for the passivity with which she greets fate laid out in the tarot cards later (scene from Act 3 pictured below).
O'Sullivan and her Don Jose (Atalla Ayan) have a kind of anti-chemistry. He has a wide face, slightly receding hairline, and puppy dog eyes. It's the kind of face that can convey anguish and worry easily. Set against O'Sullivan's movie-star looks, they each reinforce their unsuitability to the other to great dramatic effect. Atalla is a superb tenor though his voice was low and tinny at times. I wondered whether O'Sullivan might have benefitted more from the 'umpf' of a heldentenor in duets (such as Jon Vickers) but Ayan surprised, revving the tenor range and projecting more in the duets.
When she's tied up after the affray in the factory, Carmen is approached by Zuniga (John Molloy). He touches her face with his outstretched palm, then the area right above her bosom, and (it is implied) on the buttocks. Molloy's Zuniga, with thinning hair made slightly bouffant, a wispy moustache and militaristic bass-baritone exudes authority and arrogance throughout, made all the more vivid by the physical contrast between him and Ayan. Zuniga rips off her work apron leaving Carmen in a figure-hugging red dress, and holds the apron to his face.
Carmen shouts during the violation, but recovers quickly and sets her sights on Jose. This display of brutality and Carmen's quick “recovery” is jarring and lingers. On the one hand, she has turned sexual desire for her into a weapon – the intelligent and fiercely independent Carmen O'Sullivan sought to craft. She bounces back from such a violation. Perhaps she's used to it. Absorbed it. She doesn't wallow. Picks up the pieces. On the other hand, she has shut herself off from the possibility of real love. This is a Carmen who knows her world and its pathologies, seeing them as things to be negotiated and navigated, not dwelling on abstract injustice. O'Sullivan captured this wily intelligence.
In the next act she's in the bar dancing sultrily as she sings the Castanet Aria while José is seated in front of her with his back to the audience. At the opening of the Flower Song, it is Carmen who is seated on the head of the chair, with the pantyhose of her thighs exposed. In a stunning bit of risqué, José gets closer and closer to her inner thigh until it seems his face is resting alongside it. Paradoxically, such a sexual moment is devoid of sexual desire. Carmen becomes less animated, José more distressed. During the soaring denouement of the Flower Song, O'Sullivan stares blankly and impassively out at the audience as Ayan belts the climax with gusto.
A 1950s theme pervades the set and costumes. Escamillo (David Bizic) is a James Dean/Elvis/Fonzie type figure in a leather jacket and jeans. He sings the Toreador directly to the audience through a chrome-plated Shure microphone on a stand. Jade Phoenix is one of the stars of this production as Frasquita. An exceptionally powerful soprano with a natural charisma on stage, she commanded attention, even at moments when she was not a protagonist. She has great comedic facial expressions and timing, demonstrated during the card trio scene when she lunged toward the audience, beaming at the prospect of being a rich widow.
The third act takes place in an elongated concrete warehouse with oblique windows running along the right-side wall, reminiscent of Michael Jackson's Smooth Criminal music video. The bandits, in black leather jackets, bring their loot in boxes. Carmen, in a leather trenchcoat, blends in seamlessly with the criminals. The scene turns burlesque as Frasquita and Mercedes face the audience and provocatively put on pantyhose. Whether or not it was a nod to Charlie Chaplin's A Burlesque on Carmen (where the Don Jose equivalent is named “Darn Hosiery”), it adds to the sexualised air of the production. Micaëla's aria is sung beautifully by Stacey Allaume (pictured above), but with little of the vulnerability that matches the Act One prayer. As she sings of Don Jose's mother in Act 1, Carmen looks at the audience, smirking and rolling her eyes. It's a display of ruthlessness that puts Escamillo's claims of Carmen's fickleness into perspective. Perhaps maternal love and unconditional romantic love are incomprehensible to her.
The final act was a glorious splash of colour and confetti featuring somersaults by an acrobatic troupe. The brutality towards Carmen returned when an unkempt José descended from a balcony and implored pathetically. Carmen's frilly red dress, cut off in the lower half, gave a sense of an impending sexual assault as José dragged her, pinned her up against a pillar and ripped off one of her sleeves. We were spared such an awful spectacle by an equally awful one – José put Carmen on her knees, facing the audience, as he crouched behind her and slit her throat from ear to ear. She keeled over and splayed out, dead. He stood up and turned the knife on himself. As he fell, the curtain closed.
This is a co-production with Opera Philadelphia and Seattle Opera, directed by Paul Curran. It is highly cinematic with an excellent cast. The orchestra could have played the preludes to the acts with a bit more verve, but such trifles are easily forgivable for such an amazing production. INO should seriously consider touring this abroad.