thu 13/03/2025
Home > new music > CD: Susan Boyle - Someone to Watch Over Me

CD: Susan Boyle - Someone to Watch Over Me | reviews, news & interviews

CD: Susan Boyle - Someone to Watch Over Me

CD: Susan Boyle - Someone to Watch Over Me

Talent show phenomenon hints at the kind of music Simon Cowell wants to spoil next

by Wednesday, 02 November 2011
Share

The biggest surprise with Someone to Watch Over Me might be that SuBo has actually made it to three albums. Last year’s release brought relief that the Simon Cowell machine hadn’t broken her. But with this new one Boyle actually seems to be forging a career of sorts. So, now that she no longer has the novelty value of being a current "reality TV" phenomenon, and three LPs in, how does her music stand up?

Considering Boyle’s act was the stuff of a prime-time talent show, it's hardly a revelation that this record offers a few saccharine moments with a general feeling that, because of its release, Christmas must be close by. It isn't, however, quite as predictable as the ones before. There is something slightly interesting in the choice of songs included. The Syco press release (Simon Cowell’s record label) says that in addition to the “breathtaking renditions” of “Unchained Melody” and “Both Sides Now”, Susan “fearlessly takes on” “Enjoy the Silence” (Depeche Mode) and “Mad World” (Tears for Fears).

Leaving aside that the word “competently” would have been more accurate, I am surprised they omit to mention Boyle’s take on the Jeff Buckley cover of “Lilac Wine”. Not only is it the best thing on here, but it is also better than X- Factor winner Alexandra Burke’s hideous take on Buckley’s reading of Leonard Cohen's “Hallelujah”. Or her own on The Gift, for that matter.

Other than suggesting what's on Boyle's iPod, it seems likely that the track listing on this album also indicates what sort of “modern classic” Simon Cowell's intending to spoil for us soon. Still there's nothing on this record that is actually that awful, and some moments are endearing. The touch is lighter than before, and moreover, it’s not masquerading as anything it isn’t. Bland and kitsch, it surely is, but that's still fine for a track or two at an ironic Christmas party or a stocking filler.  

Watch Susan Boyle sing "I Dreamed a Dream" on Britain's Got Talent


 

Comments

Submitted by Manele (not verified) on Wed, 02/11/2011 - 10:11
I don't find her voice extraordinary so I don't understand the goosebumps I get when I listen to this short snippet. Of course, I'll be getting this :)

Submitted by dave (not verified) on Sun, 06/11/2011 - 11:07
Totally agree, I don't understand to goosebumps either. In fact I think she is sooooo overated.

Submitted by Robert (not verified) on Wed, 02/11/2011 - 10:25
Your opinion is reassuring. If a snobby arty farty metropolitan music critic does not like it, it is bound to sell in shed loads. As usual, your disdain for what 'Joe Public' likes is astounding. Ms Boyle - you have a wonderful voice - ignore cretins like these - you go girl!

Submitted by Mike Danata (not verified) on Wed, 02/11/2011 - 10:44
This may well be the most successful, of all of Susan's recordings so far. It is sure to become a massive seller, & with good reason, she CAN actually sing! Can't wait for the Musical next year, & her appearance in it, it also will be a big hit......................

Submitted by KJ (not verified) on Wed, 02/11/2011 - 12:15
Considering the snide remarks that Ms Boyle usually elicits from 'professional' reviewers this must rate as a rave. As a simple music lover I respond to her honesty of voice and am confident this will be another hit album for her. I do, however, wish the SYCO machine would let her sing a few more 'big' songs that would suit her so well. Look forward eagerly to her next album!

Submitted by amandanoa (not verified) on Wed, 02/11/2011 - 19:47
I feel like this review is more about you disliking Simon Cowell than anything to do with Susan Boyle. Susan has a lovely voice and what I've heard of this album has been wonderful. I will definitely be buying this, my third SB album, as I'm sure will be many around the world. You can say all the negative things you like while Susan and Simon are pocketing the money and laughing at you.

Submitted by Karen (not verified) on Thu, 03/11/2011 - 00:00
I bought my CD yesterday and I LOVE it. The track list is very unique and not something I would have expected from Susan Boyle, and her vocals are gorgeous! I'll be buying several to give as Christmas gifts. I can't stand Simon Cowell but rather than hold the fact that she was discovered on one of his shows against her, I'll have to actually say thank you to him. This CD will give me a lot of pleasure for years to come.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/11/2011 - 01:28
Susan knocks another one out of the ballpark! Beautiful voice, beautiful selection of songs as she makes each one her own. Susan continues to grow and push herself as an artist. What a joy to listen to this latest album of Susan's!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/11/2011 - 01:49
My, aren't you artistically superior!! Damning with faint praise is not attractive, Mr Coffey. "Not that bad" indeed. Your job was not to review Simon Cowell but the merits of this album the which, by the way, was a fairly poor job. I'm not sure why you are "surprised" that she is "forging a career of sorts". She sold over 3 million albums in the first week of her debut album, 14 million albums in 14 months, is in the Guinnes Book of World Records three times, was voted the 3rd most influential woman in the world in 2010, has performed around the globe and has garnered praise from Barbra Streisand to Billboard and will take part in a musical based on her life in 2012. This woman was not an "overnight reality show success" She paid her dues in clubs around Scotland for years. Don't care for her music if you like, everyone has his/her own musical tastes, but at least have the honesty to say you judge Susan Boyle, not by her talent, but by the fact that she in on Simon Cowell's label.

Submitted by Craig (not verified) on Fri, 04/11/2011 - 23:53
Oh dear you really are as sad and pathetic as you appear in your photo. How can you be a paid critic and still be so out of touch, with how the public feel about Ms Boyle? She has paid her dues working small venues etc. Now, stop trying to be clever and give her a break or just put a cork in it.

Submitted by dave (not verified) on Sun, 06/11/2011 - 11:04
Why do people consider "Lilac Wine " a cover of a Jeff Buckley" ??? It has been recorded by many people including Nina Simone, and Elkie Brooks. The only version to have chart success is by Elkie Brooks in 1978. So for me" Lilac Wine " is a cover of the Elkie Brooks hit.

Submitted by dave (not verified) on Sun, 06/11/2011 - 11:09
Lilac Wine is an Elkie Brooks hit !!!! The U.K.s best singer.

Submitted by John (Subo fan) (not verified) on Tue, 08/11/2011 - 14:01
Before any Subo fan tries to slit my throat, let me first explain that I AM a Susan Boyle fan myself. I don't think this album will enhance Ms. Boyle career one bit. I consider this album to be a total rip-off. Why ? At little over 30 odd minutes playing time....that's a bit much to ask her of her fans to part with their hard earned money. At least 4 additional songs would have been better value for money. The title track "Someone To Watch Over Me" is only a fraction over ONE minute long ??? I don't blame Ms. Boyle for these shortcomings, but her management team. I suspect Mr. Cowell insisted the album was released to cash in on Christmas sales regardless of its actual content.

Add comment

The future of Arts Journalism

 

You can stop theartsdesk.com closing!

We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £33,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d

And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

more New music

First Person: singer-songwriter David Gray on how the songs on his new album came to him One of this century's most successful British singers still finds magic in the act of creation
Album: Steven Wilson - The Overview Infectious prog concept LP ponders Earth's insignificance and what lies beyond
Album: Coheed and Cambria - The Father of Make Believe An impressive welcome back to the group's imaginitive universe
Album: Reg Meuross, Fire & Dust: A Woody Guthrie Story At once a celebration and an exploration of the timeless Dust Bowl Balladeer
Music Reissues Weekly: Liverpool Sunset - The City After Merseybeat Times changed, but the city which birthed The Beatles still came up with the goods
Album: Lady Gaga - Mayhem The godmother of theatre-kid pop is back! Back!! BACK!!!
Album: Spiritbox - Tsunami Sea Second album from Canadian metalcore band is a sonic assault yet graceful and beautiful
Album: The Burning Hell - Ghost Palace Reflective Canadians interpret an increasingly unfathomable world
Chuck Prophet, Mid Sussex Music Hall, Hassocks review - the good American Liberating, humane rock'n'roll from an unassuming master
Album: Anoushka Shankar - Chapter III: We Return to Light Sitar titan blends the sounds of modern India into her travelogue triptych
Album: Jethro Tull - Curious Ruminant Tull burst out again with a set of bristling folk-prog anthems
Music Reissues Weekly: Kraftwerk - Autobahn at 50 A reminder of changing perspectives

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters