Mary Page Marlowe, Old Vic review - a starry portrait of a splintered life

Tracy Letts's Off Broadway play makes a shimmeringly powerful London debut

I came late to the Old Vic's shimmering production of Mary Page Marlowe, Tracy Letts's Off Broadway play from 2018 which has arrived in London with Andrea Riseborough and Susan Sarandon leading a sizable and uniformly excellent cast. And I hope theatregoers will catch this too-short run while they can. Amidst ongoing chat – sometimes justified – about screen stars not being able to hold their own stage, Matthew Warchus's keenly attuned staging proves that just as often they very much can.

The Unbelievers, Royal Court Theatre - grimly compelling, powerfully performed

★★★★ THE UNBELIEVERS, ROYAL COURT THEATRE Nick Payne's new play is amongst his best

Nick Payne's new play is amongst his best

Change, we're often told, is the engine of drama: people end up somewhere markedly different from where they began. So the first thing to be said about Nick Payne's blistering new play The Unbelievers is that its concept is as brave as leading lady Nicola Walker's take-no-prisoners performance.

50 First Dates: The Musical, The Other Palace review - romcom turned musical

 50 FIRST DATES: THE MUSICAL, THE OTHER PALACE Forgettable, but comforting

Date movie about repeating dates inspires date musical

About halfway through this world premiere, I realised what was missing. Where is the sinister lift, where are the long corridors and, most of all, WHERE IS MR. MILCHICK? 50 First Dates: The Musical may indeed be the sunnier cousin of Severance, but it’s also much older, tracing its roots back to the mid-hit movie of the same name.

Reunion, Kiln Theatre review - a stormy night in every sense

 REUNION, KILN THEATRE New play brings a family's old enmities to the surface

Beautifully acted, but desperately grim drama

If you ever wanted to know what a mash up of Martin McDonagh and Conor McPherson, stirred (and there’s a lot of stirring in this play) with a soupçon of Chekhov, Ibsen and Williams looks like, The Kiln has your answer.

The Lady from the Sea, Bridge Theatre review - flashes of brilliance

Simon Stone refashions Ibsen in his own high-octane image

Like the lighting that crackles now and again to indicate an abrupt change of scene or mood, Simon Stone's version of The Lady from the Sea is illuminated by the sense of adventure and excitement one has come to expect from this singular artist. That's the case even if the cumulative effect falls short of his devastating achievements with the National Theatre's Phaedra or, before that, Billie Piper in Yerma

Maiden Voyage, Southwark Playhouse review - new musical runs aground

 MAIDEN VOYAGE, SOUTHWARK PLAYHOUSE All women crew sail around the world, singing, grouching and bonding

Pleasant tunes well sung and a good story, but not a good show

As the nation basks in the reflected glory of The Lionesses' Euro25 victory, it could hardly be more timely for the Southwark Playhouse to launch a new musical that tells the tale of The Maiden. That was the boat, built and sailed by Tracy Edwards and her crew of resourceful, resilient women, in the Whitbread Round The World Yacht Race 1989, the first such crew to finish the gruelling challenge.

Poor Clare, Orange Tree Theatre review - saints cajole us sinners

★ POOR CLARE, ORANGE TREE THEATRE Chira Atik's award-winning comedy packs a punch

Funny and clever show illuminated by a dazzling debut from Arsema Thomas

What am I, a philosophical if not political Marxist whose hero is Antonio Gramsci, doing in Harvey Nichols buying Comme des Garçons linen jackets, Church brogues and Mulberry shades? It’s 1987 and I do wear it well though…

The Brightening Air, Old Vic review - Chekhov jostles Conor McPherson in writer-director's latest

★★★ THE BRIGHTENING AIR, OLD VIC Chekhov jostles Conor McPherson in writer's latest

The Irishman's first new play in over a decade is engaging but overstuffed

It's one thing to be indebted to a playwright, as Tom Stoppard and Harold Pinter have been at different times to Beckett, or Sondheim's latest musical is to Sartre. But Conor McPherson's The Brightening Air – the title itself is derived from Yeats – comes so fully steeped in Chekhov that you may wonder whether this portrait of rural Ireland in 1980s County Sligo hasn't bled into provincial Russia from nearly a century before, or vice-versa.

My Master Builder, Wyndham's Theatre review - Ewan McGregor headlines stillborn Ibsen riff

★★ MY MASTER BUILDER, WYNDHAM'S THEATRE Ewan McGregor headlines stillborn Ibsen riff

Starry new writing premiere struggles to connect

It's both brave and bracing to welcome new voices to the West End, but sometimes one wonders if such exposure necessarily works to the benefit of those involved. And so it is with My Master Builder, American writer Lila Raicek's Ibsen-adjacent play that nods throughout at the Norwegian scribe's scorching 1892 The Master Builder only to suggest that director Michael Grandage might have been better off staging that classic title instead: his Wild Duck, dating back to his Donmar tenancy, remains the stuff of legend.