Beyond the Pole | reviews, news & interviews
Beyond the Pole
Beyond the Pole
Polar ice cap is the star of British eco-comedy
Tuesday, 09 February 2010
Do the words “British film comedy” cause your heart to sink as deeply as they do mine? Thought so. I wish I could say Beyond the Pole, which is perhaps the first eco-comedy and was made with the intention of raising awareness about polar melting while making us laugh, was worth the effort. Sadly, it wasn’t. It may throw up the odd chuckle, but mostly it’s predictable and unoriginal. The scenery, however, is stunning.
Beyond the Pole was originally a Radio 4 series and its co-writer Neil Warhurst wrote the screenplay. The film's co-writer and director David L Williams, who filmed it on the Greenland ice cap, has created a mockumentary in which we follow Stephen Mangan and Rhys Thomas as Mark and Brian, endearing innocents who want to save the planet and decide to walk unaided to the North Pole to do their bit.
They have no experience (although Mark feels qualified because his great-grandfather was a polar explorer and Brian... well, he loves watching extreme sports on the telly), no funding and no realisation of the dangers they face. The trip will be “the first carbon-neutral, organic and vegetarian” and they hope to get into the record books.
Of course it goes horribly wrong. Their cameraman Steve (Clive Russell) has to be airlifted off the ice after a polar-bear attack and two ultra-professional Norwegians, equally carbon-neutral, organic and vegetarian, are close on Mark and Brian’s tail. But the intrepid Brits continue, amid much foul-mouthed bickering as they capture the rest of their journey on camcorders, Ellen MacArthur/Vendée Globe-style. (Actually I can never think of the brave yachtswoman’s pieces to camera without Jan Raven’s hilariously tear-stained versions on Dead Ringers hoving into view.)
The characterisations are weak, lazy even, and rely on the audience’s foreknowledge of the actors’ television careers. Mangan (from Green Wing) as a deluded social misfit? Check. Thomas (Bellamy’s People) as a likeable dunderhead? Check. Helen Baxendale (Cold Feet) as a haughty documentary maker? Mark Benton (Nationwide ads on TV) as their useless communications man, a CB radio geek who of course lives in a caravan? Check, check, check, check, check. And as for the film’s fly-on-the-wall documentary style - that has been done to death on British television and, besides, no one will ever improve on The Office.
If Beyond the Pole starts out as a comedy, about an hour in Williams suddenly changes gear and goes a bit Blair Witch Project on us as Mark descends into madness, Brian loses the will to live and the pair lose contact with the outside world. But it happens so quickly we don’t believe it and, frustratingly, the idea is not developed.
To be fair there are some funny moments, such as Brian continually falling behind and sinking into the snow in the distance and the sweary shouting between the two men, and there’s a very neat story twist to bring the action back to Blighty. The location is the film’s real star, but I’m not sure it justifies the end product - as the green lobby is wont to ask, was the journey really necessary?
On general release from Friday. Visit the film website here
They have no experience (although Mark feels qualified because his great-grandfather was a polar explorer and Brian... well, he loves watching extreme sports on the telly), no funding and no realisation of the dangers they face. The trip will be “the first carbon-neutral, organic and vegetarian” and they hope to get into the record books.
Of course it goes horribly wrong. Their cameraman Steve (Clive Russell) has to be airlifted off the ice after a polar-bear attack and two ultra-professional Norwegians, equally carbon-neutral, organic and vegetarian, are close on Mark and Brian’s tail. But the intrepid Brits continue, amid much foul-mouthed bickering as they capture the rest of their journey on camcorders, Ellen MacArthur/Vendée Globe-style. (Actually I can never think of the brave yachtswoman’s pieces to camera without Jan Raven’s hilariously tear-stained versions on Dead Ringers hoving into view.)
The characterisations are weak, lazy even, and rely on the audience’s foreknowledge of the actors’ television careers. Mangan (from Green Wing) as a deluded social misfit? Check. Thomas (Bellamy’s People) as a likeable dunderhead? Check. Helen Baxendale (Cold Feet) as a haughty documentary maker? Mark Benton (Nationwide ads on TV) as their useless communications man, a CB radio geek who of course lives in a caravan? Check, check, check, check, check. And as for the film’s fly-on-the-wall documentary style - that has been done to death on British television and, besides, no one will ever improve on The Office.
If Beyond the Pole starts out as a comedy, about an hour in Williams suddenly changes gear and goes a bit Blair Witch Project on us as Mark descends into madness, Brian loses the will to live and the pair lose contact with the outside world. But it happens so quickly we don’t believe it and, frustratingly, the idea is not developed.
To be fair there are some funny moments, such as Brian continually falling behind and sinking into the snow in the distance and the sweary shouting between the two men, and there’s a very neat story twist to bring the action back to Blighty. The location is the film’s real star, but I’m not sure it justifies the end product - as the green lobby is wont to ask, was the journey really necessary?
On general release from Friday. Visit the film website here
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take a subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Film
Love Lies Bleeding review - a pumped-up neo-noir
There's darkness on the edge of town in Rose Glass's sweaty, violent New Queer gem
Nezouh review - seeking magic in a war
A movie that looks on the dreamier side of Syrian strife
Blu-ray: The Dreamers
Bertolucci revisits May '68 via intoxicated, transgressive sex, lit up by the debuting Eva Green
theartsdesk Q&A: Marco Bellocchio - the last maestro
Italian cinema's vigorous grand old man discusses Kidnapped, conversion, anarchy and faith in cinema
I.S.S. review - sci-fi with a sting in the tail
The imperilled space station isn't the worst place to be
That They May Face The Rising Sun review - lyrical adaptation of John McGahern's novel
Pat Collins extracts the magic of country life in the west of Ireland in his third feature film
Stephen review - a breathtakingly good first feature by a multi-media artist
Melanie Manchot's debut is strikingly intelligent and compelling
DVD/Blu-Ray: Priscilla
The disc extras smartly contextualise Sofia Coppola's eighth feature
Fantastic Machine review - photography's story from one camera to 45 billion
Love it or hate it, the photographic image has ensnared us all
All You Need Is Death review - a future folk horror classic
Irish folkies seek a cursed ancient song in Paul Duane's impressive fiction debut
If Only I Could Hibernate review - kids in grinding poverty in Ulaanbaatar
Mongolian director Zoljargal Purevdash's compelling debut
The Book of Clarence review - larky jaunt through biblical epic territory
LaKeith Stanfield is impressively watchable as the Messiah's near-neighbour
Add comment