Hannah review - Rampling's restrained passion burns bright

Slow-burning minimalism with an emotional punch

share this article

Charlotte Rampling as Hannah

Hannah is a vehicle for Charlotte Rampling, and it's no wonder she won the Best Actress Award for her role at Venice in 2018.  The film follows her as she gradually falls to pieces, without a trace of hysteria, slowly and surely, with her husband in prison for reasons that are never clear.

Hannah works as a maid in a wealthy household, where she shows tenderness to a slightly disturbed child. She goes to an acting workshop that mirrors, in a strange way, her own increasing alienation, rather than nourishing her soul. There is a leak from the apartment above which she has to deal with. Her dog, who was deeply attached to the now imprisoned husband pines for him at the door and is eventually taken away by a father and his daughter. She makes a birthday cake for her grandson, but is turned away when she tries to deliver it by a son with whom she has fallen out. The absence of an obvious outer narrative and the focus on Hannah’s inner turmoil and desperation gives the prosaic a force and mystery that are at times quite startling and feel, paradoxically, more authentic.

This is a film that doesn’t attempt to seduce in the conventional way, but lures you instead with a pace that at first feels languid, but that reveals its power as the episodic moments in the intimate company of Hannah follow each other with a logic that draws strength from mystery rather than explicit narrative. We are immersed into Hannah’s increasing desperation by stealth: there are lengthy shots without any movement at all. I may be wrong but I think the first serious camera movement, a slow almost imperceptible tracking shot, appears 30 minutes in. The framing is often counter-intuitive, with Hannah on the edge of frame, in reflection or in back view. The director allows us – or rather forces us – to focus on Charlotte Rampling’s lined face, eyes that express an almost unbearably sadness. The minimalism of Pallaoro’s approach creates, as the film progresses, incredibly intense emotion rather than the coldness that his apparent formalism might require.

The relentless gloom and hopeless isolation of the central character avoids pathos or sentimentality – the formal elegance of the film makes sure of that. Instead, the film builds towards an emotional climax that is in fact not a climax at all, but an experience of deep empathy with the character brought to life by Rampling, and an understanding that is anything but intellectual of the aloneness that growing old inevitably entails.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
This is a film that doesn’t attempt to seduce in the conventional way

rating

5

explore topics

share this article

the future of arts journalism

You can stop theartsdesk.com closing! 

We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £33,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d

And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

more film

The prolific French director probes more than existential alienation in this deceptively beautiful film
The Ukrainian writer-director discusses 'Soviet justice' and the trouble with history repeating itself
S&M shenanigans turn serious in Peter Medak's complex '60s thriller
Russia's Tarantino's Hollywood debut is derivative but delirious
A lawyer sinks into a bureaucratic quagmire in a darkly humane Stalinist parable
Taut, engrossing low-budget thriller from an underrated director
The Italian star talks about his third portrayal of an Italian head of state
Sorrentino's latest political character study is cast in shades of grieving grey
Ryan Gosling fights to save Earth in a family sf epic of rare optimism
The little guy against the system: Bill Skarsgård and Dacre Montgomery star
'One Battle After Another' is the big winner over 'Sinners' amid a leaden Oscars that mixed impassioned politics with too much painful filler
A curious, cautious tale about sampling the Führer’s grub