Help keep arts journalism alive.

We’re rebuilding theartsdesk to secure it as a bastion of real culture writing in the face of algorithmic recommendations and AI slop. Your participation is absolutely vital to this - subscribe today and be part of this movement.

SUBSCRIBE TODAY 

CD: Dido - Girl Who Got Away

Multi-million-selling modern M.O.R. queen's fourth is business as usual

share this article

Dido getting away, possibly from predictable music journalists

Dido Armstrong’s first two albums are at numbers 19 and 29 in the UK’s all time best-sellers. The 41-year-old singer became an emblem of post-millennial dinner parties, of Bridget Jones-era singleton moping, and of post-electronica easy listening. Her success was massive but with it she became an easy target, mainly because she emanates Mogadon melancholy without emotional depth.

OK I admit I loathe everything she put her hand to although I confess a soft spot for the chorus of “White Flag” – “I will go down with this ship/I won’t put my hands up and surrender/There will be no white flag upon my door”. If only someone else had written the rest of the song, as happened when Eminem nicked the chorus of “Thank You” to create his and her mega-breakthrough, “Stan”.

I find sparse critical objectivity running to the hills as my ears are confronted by Dido’s fourth. It’s business as usual, which means her brother Rollo from Faithless is on production duties as her airy white-bread voice breathes condensation onto wet, careful balladeering, the whole attached to electronic backing that’s 50 percent trancey chill-out, 30 percent trip hop and 20 percent Enya-alike. In truth, if some of this had appeared on a low-key French label back in the late Nineties, the cleverly smooth “Blackbird”, might now be regarded as lost late-Balearic classic. But it didn’t and isn't. And Greg Kurstin, co-writer of Lily Allen’s superb It’s Not Me, It’s You album, deserves a mention for “End of the Night” which recalls William Orbit & Madonna. Incongruously, Brian Eno also assists on the final "Day Before We Went to War" (he was also on her last album) although it’s still only the usual Dido schtick with a slightly Tubular Bells vibe thrown in. So. There we go. It's all very, very… pleasant. And soporific. Can I turn it off now?

Watch the video for "No Freedom"

I find my sparse critical objectivity running to the hills

rating

2

explore topics

share this article

more new music

Bono and Co set loose the last of their latest sessions with Jacknife Lee
Industrial trio turn dread inside out for a party at the end of the world
Rising Arizona-via-New York singer with a predictable but solid outing
The East London singer taps into a deep stream of sophisticated UK soul-reggae-jazz interplay
Early 1960's John Coltrane amateur club recordings - traces at the cliff-edge
Frenetic, funny and dancefloor-friendly, the cartoonish cult act are a boisterous good time
A tightly-knit community of emerging musicians with high standards at Riga Music Week
Jungle meets joystick with one of Japan’s most enduring electronic-club producers
Wilson lights a fire under English rural weirdness on his ninth solo outing
The powerful genre-busting performer revisits some of her best tunes
A night at the medina jazz club, and meeting the founder of the city’s first jazz festival
Doom and dorkiness mark the singer's post-Traitors return