Help keep arts journalism alive.

We’re rebuilding theartsdesk to secure it as a bastion of real culture writing in the face of algorithmic recommendations and AI slop. Your participation is absolutely vital to this - subscribe today and be part of this movement.

SUBSCRIBE TODAY 

CD: Modestep - Evolution Theory

Dubstep-rock: an evolutionary leap forward?

share this article

Evolution Theory: not quite the great leap forward

There are so many people ready to hate pop-rock-dubstep crossover band Modestep, and no wonder. They are good looking young men, taking what they want from whatever styles are around them, without any regard for cool or hipness. They make a massive racket full of screeching and crashing noises blended with cheesy melodies, which seems pretty much aimed at attracting girls and getting boys throwing themselves around like fools. They are, in short, everything old people have always hated about young people's music.

If you want to hate them too, it's not difficult: there are some very crap bits on their debut album. The crass attempts at political comment on “Praying for Silence” and the nudge-nudge weed-smoking lyrics and attempts at vocal interplay with grime MCs Footsie and D Double E on “Burn” should make any sane person's teeth twist in their mouth with embarrassment, for example. The lurches between fizzing pop-trance synths, heavy guitars and splurging, blurting dubstep basslines on tracks like the single “Sunshine” can be pretty clumsy to say the least. They don't half rip off Muse a lot too.

And yet, and yet... more often than it trips up, it works. The multiple rappers on the album's title track narrating recent underground music history sound rousing rather than tokenistic. The adrenaline rushes of metal, dubstep and drum'n'bass are so expertly deployed that however tacky a track might be for the first minute or two, the moment it really gets going, you're swept along with it. The dynamics and the playing could only have come from a hard-gigging band, and the sense of sweat and sex likewise. This is in many ways a very silly record, but it's certainly worthy of a lot more than mindless derision.

Watch the video for "Another Day"


If you want to hate Modestep, it's not difficult: there are some very crap bits on their debut album

rating

3

explore topics

share this article

more new music

The biggest concert of the 2026 EFG London Jazz Festival
The jazz saxophonist and hip-hop player explores what it means to be political in the 2020s
The Los Angeles trio offered plenty of catchy pop tunes, but a lack of variety was frustrating
Two very different avant-garde talents conjure a micro-album of dream ballads
Heavy and intense industrial goth-rock from 2011 with remixes & a full live gig soundtrack
The singular singer-songwriter follows her Sandy Denny project with a powerful album of folk ballads
Dance music’s go-to voice turns caustic and candid, and it’s surprisingly relatable
Bono and Co set loose the last of their latest sessions with Jacknife Lee
Industrial trio turn dread inside out for a party at the end of the world
Rising Arizona-via-New York singer with a predictable but solid outing
The East London singer taps into a deep stream of sophisticated UK soul-reggae-jazz interplay