Lion's Den | reviews, news & interviews
Lion's Den
Lion's Den
Women behind bars in a thrilling prison drama from Argentina
Thursday, 25 March 2010  
 
  
            Since his astonishing debut Crane World a decade ago, the Argentine  Pablo Trapero has been quietly asserting himself as one of the world’s  most singular directors. He’s perhaps best known for his breezy verité approach – shooting on location, often using non-actors, and drawing his  subjects from everyday Argentine life. At the same time, Trapero has  always dallied, slyly, with genre: Rolling Family might be called a road  movie, El Bonaerense a cop drama, though each is subverted so as to  accord with his desire to be true to quotidian reality.
        
        
	Lion’s Den (Leonera) is a case in point. Ostensibly a prison movie, in Trapero’s hands the genre feels as fresh and reconfigured as it does in Jacques Audiard’s A Prophet. Shot in real prisons, and integrating professional actors with actual inmates, it can be seen as a continuation of his modus operandi. But there’s a sense, too, that with this film the director is beginning to flex his muscles, in terms of both technique and story; inching, quite consciously, towards an ever-greater audience.
 It starts with a brilliant depiction of post-traumatic shock. Julia Zarate (Martina Gusman) wakes up in her apartment, showers, takes a train to work, sits in her office, distractedly scraping blood off her hands, takes the train home again, enters. Only then does she “see” and is overwhelmed by the violence she had left behind.
It starts with a brilliant depiction of post-traumatic shock. Julia Zarate (Martina Gusman) wakes up in her apartment, showers, takes a train to work, sits in her office, distractedly scraping blood off her hands, takes the train home again, enters. Only then does she “see” and is overwhelmed by the violence she had left behind. 
What immediately follows plays like a justice system procedural: from the crime scene, to the court where Julia is charged – for a murder she can’t remember committing – and refused bail, to her arrival in a women’s prison, all shown dialogue-light, matter-of-fact, almost documentary-style. This prologue, persuasive and absorbing, establishes the tone of the story that follows, of this young woman’s very particular time in prison.
For Julia is pregnant (the father, she claims, being the man she is accused of killing). As such, she is placed in a maternal cell block, occupied by women who are either pregnant or have their babies and toddlers with them before, at four years old, they must part company. Julia gives birth in confinement and then, as her case takes years to reach trial, fights for the right to have her child remain with her inside.
The plot is moved along by the four key relationships of Julia’s incarceration: with her mother, from whom she is estranged and who plays a malign role in the fate of the boy, Tomás; a fellow prisoner and mother, Marta (Laura Garcia); her co-defendant, Ramiro (Rodrigo Santoro), of whose sole guilt we can be reasonably sure; and with Tomás himself.
 In the background, Trapero creates a palpable sense of life inside for these hard-luck mothers, most of whom are not as the middle-class Julia, but Marta, who when asked why she’s in jail answers: “Because I’m poor. Because I’m a fucking fool.” Trapero has a way of eliciting the most unaffected performances from his non-actors, and here is no exception. We believe their mutual dependency, their shared frustration when a newborn keeps the whole block awake, their defence of one another before the guards, in language so ferociously foul, it’s comic. All the while, passing time is measured by the growth of children, by a sunny parade to kindergarten and Santa dancing atop the prison walls.
In the background, Trapero creates a palpable sense of life inside for these hard-luck mothers, most of whom are not as the middle-class Julia, but Marta, who when asked why she’s in jail answers: “Because I’m poor. Because I’m a fucking fool.” Trapero has a way of eliciting the most unaffected performances from his non-actors, and here is no exception. We believe their mutual dependency, their shared frustration when a newborn keeps the whole block awake, their defence of one another before the guards, in language so ferociously foul, it’s comic. All the while, passing time is measured by the growth of children, by a sunny parade to kindergarten and Santa dancing atop the prison walls. 
But the film is chiefly characterised by two things: a knock-out central performance, and an overtly expressed film language. Gusman (who is also Trapero’s wife and executive producer) has a sullen, compelling intensity, as she conveys a young woman’s transition from vulnerable, shell-shocked innocent, to a hardened, determined, kick-ass ma. For his part, Trapero’s shot selection consciously shapes the storytelling.
 
He employs a mobile, often tracking camera to investigate the spaces inside the prison, notably in the introduction of the cell block - a majestic, waist-high tracking shot that presents not the usual array of gnarled jailbaits, but a roll call of babes in arms. A fixed camera is used where there is action or movement: a riot scene is made surreal not just by the fact that the rioters are women, but by the serenity of its framing. And close-ups heighten the sense of claustrophobia and entrapment. Such formal rigour, allied to such empathy for his characters, suggest a hugely confident director at the top of his game.
 
 
 It starts with a brilliant depiction of post-traumatic shock. Julia Zarate (Martina Gusman) wakes up in her apartment, showers, takes a train to work, sits in her office, distractedly scraping blood off her hands, takes the train home again, enters. Only then does she “see” and is overwhelmed by the violence she had left behind.
It starts with a brilliant depiction of post-traumatic shock. Julia Zarate (Martina Gusman) wakes up in her apartment, showers, takes a train to work, sits in her office, distractedly scraping blood off her hands, takes the train home again, enters. Only then does she “see” and is overwhelmed by the violence she had left behind. What immediately follows plays like a justice system procedural: from the crime scene, to the court where Julia is charged – for a murder she can’t remember committing – and refused bail, to her arrival in a women’s prison, all shown dialogue-light, matter-of-fact, almost documentary-style. This prologue, persuasive and absorbing, establishes the tone of the story that follows, of this young woman’s very particular time in prison.
For Julia is pregnant (the father, she claims, being the man she is accused of killing). As such, she is placed in a maternal cell block, occupied by women who are either pregnant or have their babies and toddlers with them before, at four years old, they must part company. Julia gives birth in confinement and then, as her case takes years to reach trial, fights for the right to have her child remain with her inside.
The plot is moved along by the four key relationships of Julia’s incarceration: with her mother, from whom she is estranged and who plays a malign role in the fate of the boy, Tomás; a fellow prisoner and mother, Marta (Laura Garcia); her co-defendant, Ramiro (Rodrigo Santoro), of whose sole guilt we can be reasonably sure; and with Tomás himself.
 In the background, Trapero creates a palpable sense of life inside for these hard-luck mothers, most of whom are not as the middle-class Julia, but Marta, who when asked why she’s in jail answers: “Because I’m poor. Because I’m a fucking fool.” Trapero has a way of eliciting the most unaffected performances from his non-actors, and here is no exception. We believe their mutual dependency, their shared frustration when a newborn keeps the whole block awake, their defence of one another before the guards, in language so ferociously foul, it’s comic. All the while, passing time is measured by the growth of children, by a sunny parade to kindergarten and Santa dancing atop the prison walls.
In the background, Trapero creates a palpable sense of life inside for these hard-luck mothers, most of whom are not as the middle-class Julia, but Marta, who when asked why she’s in jail answers: “Because I’m poor. Because I’m a fucking fool.” Trapero has a way of eliciting the most unaffected performances from his non-actors, and here is no exception. We believe their mutual dependency, their shared frustration when a newborn keeps the whole block awake, their defence of one another before the guards, in language so ferociously foul, it’s comic. All the while, passing time is measured by the growth of children, by a sunny parade to kindergarten and Santa dancing atop the prison walls. But the film is chiefly characterised by two things: a knock-out central performance, and an overtly expressed film language. Gusman (who is also Trapero’s wife and executive producer) has a sullen, compelling intensity, as she conveys a young woman’s transition from vulnerable, shell-shocked innocent, to a hardened, determined, kick-ass ma. For his part, Trapero’s shot selection consciously shapes the storytelling.
He employs a mobile, often tracking camera to investigate the spaces inside the prison, notably in the introduction of the cell block - a majestic, waist-high tracking shot that presents not the usual array of gnarled jailbaits, but a roll call of babes in arms. A fixed camera is used where there is action or movement: a riot scene is made surreal not just by the fact that the rioters are women, but by the serenity of its framing. And close-ups heighten the sense of claustrophobia and entrapment. Such formal rigour, allied to such empathy for his characters, suggest a hugely confident director at the top of his game.
- Lion's Den opens in the UK on Friday.
- Lion's Den official website.
- Demetrios Matheou's The Faber Book of New South American Cinema is published later this year.
- Find El Bonaerense and Rolling Family on Amazon.
The future of Arts Journalism
You can stop theartsdesk.com closing!
We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £49,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d
And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take a subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Film
 Bugonia review - Yorgos Lanthimos on aliens, bees and conspiracy theories
  
  
    
      Emma Stone and Jesse Plemons excel in a marvellously deranged black comedy
  
  
    
      Bugonia review - Yorgos Lanthimos on aliens, bees and conspiracy theories
  
  
    
      Emma Stone and Jesse Plemons excel in a marvellously deranged black comedy
  
     theartsdesk Q&A: director Kelly Reichardt on 'The Mastermind' and reliving the 1970s
  
  
    
      The independent filmmaker discusses her intimate heist movie
  
  
    
      theartsdesk Q&A: director Kelly Reichardt on 'The Mastermind' and reliving the 1970s
  
  
    
      The independent filmmaker discusses her intimate heist movie
  
     Blu-ray: Wendy and Lucy
  
  
    
      Down-and-out in rural Oregon: Kelly Reichardt's third feature packs a huge punch
  
  
    
      Blu-ray: Wendy and Lucy
  
  
    
      Down-and-out in rural Oregon: Kelly Reichardt's third feature packs a huge punch
  
     The Mastermind review - another slim but nourishing slice of Americana from Kelly Reichardt
  
  
    
      Josh O'Connor is perfect casting as a cocky middle-class American adrift in the 1970s
  
  
    
      The Mastermind review - another slim but nourishing slice of Americana from Kelly Reichardt
  
  
    
      Josh O'Connor is perfect casting as a cocky middle-class American adrift in the 1970s 
  
     Springsteen: Deliver Me From Nowhere review - the story of the Boss who isn't boss of his own head
  
  
    
      A brooding trip on the Bruce Springsteen highway of hard knocks
  
  
    
      Springsteen: Deliver Me From Nowhere review - the story of the Boss who isn't boss of his own head
  
  
    
      A brooding trip on the Bruce Springsteen highway of hard knocks
  
     The Perfect Neighbor, Netflix review - Florida found-footage documentary is a harrowing watch
  
  
    
      Sundance winner chronicles a death that should have been prevented
  
  
    
      The Perfect Neighbor, Netflix review - Florida found-footage documentary is a harrowing watch
  
  
    
      Sundance winner chronicles a death that should have been prevented
  
     Blu-ray: Le Quai des Brumes 
  
  
    
      Love twinkles in the gloom of Marcel Carné’s fogbound French poetic realist classic
  
  
    
      Blu-ray: Le Quai des Brumes 
  
  
    
      Love twinkles in the gloom of Marcel Carné’s fogbound French poetic realist classic
  
     Frankenstein review - the Prometheus of the charnel house
  
  
    
      Guillermo del Toro is fitfully inspired, but often lost in long-held ambitions
  
  
    
      Frankenstein review - the Prometheus of the charnel house
  
  
    
      Guillermo del Toro is fitfully inspired, but often lost in long-held ambitions
  
     London Film Festival 2025 - a Korean masterclass in black comedy and a Camus classic effectively realised
  
  
    
      New films from Park Chan-wook, Gianfranco Rosi, François Ozon, Ildikó Enyedi and more
  
  
    
      London Film Festival 2025 - a Korean masterclass in black comedy and a Camus classic effectively realised
  
  
    
      New films from Park Chan-wook, Gianfranco Rosi, François Ozon, Ildikó Enyedi and more
  
     After the Hunt review - muddled #MeToo provocation 
  
  
    
      Julia Roberts excels despite misfiring drama
  
  
    
      After the Hunt review - muddled #MeToo provocation 
  
  
    
      Julia Roberts excels despite misfiring drama
  
     Ballad of a Small Player review - Colin Farrell's all in as a gambler down on his luck
  
  
    
      Conclave director Edward Berger swaps the Vatican for Asia's sin city
  
  
    
      Ballad of a Small Player review - Colin Farrell's all in as a gambler down on his luck
  
  
    
      Conclave director Edward Berger swaps the Vatican for Asia's sin city
  
     London Film Festival 2025 - Bradley Cooper channels John Bishop, the Boss goes to Nebraska, and a French pandemic 
  
  
    
      ... not to mention Kristen Stewart's directing debut and a punchy prison drama
  
  
    
      London Film Festival 2025 - Bradley Cooper channels John Bishop, the Boss goes to Nebraska, and a French pandemic 
  
  
    
      ... not to mention Kristen Stewart's directing debut and a punchy prison drama
  
    
Add comment