Defying Gravity, BBC Two | reviews, news & interviews
Defying Gravity, BBC Two
Defying Gravity, BBC Two
Astronauts suffer on six-year space mission, and now it's your turn
Wednesday, 21 October 2009
In space, no-one can hear you snore. The opening two-parter of Defying Gravity introduced us, in a sluggish and tortuous manner, to the six-year mission of the spacecraft Antares, which contains eight astronauts and will visit seven planets, starting with Venus. Everything was meant to be stirring and momentous as mankind took up the baton previously lifted by the likes of Vasco da Gama and Neil Armstrong, to pursue the quest for knowledge and new frontiers. More prosaically, the trade journals tell us that Antares may be brought down by networks pulling the financial plug before it can be guided to its destiny by the mysterious life form lurking in the ship's Pod 4.
A British/American/Canadian/German co-production, Defying Gravity could hardly avoid suffering from design by committee. This surfaced most prominently in an ostentatious walk-on by Peter Howitt (who also directs several episodes) as a pushy British TV journalist, deliberately goading flight engineer Maddux (yep, that’s how they’re spelling it) Donner with questions about why he left two fellow astronauts to die on Mars 10 years earlier. And would you believe it, the ship’s pilot Nadia Schilling is played by German actress Florentine Lahme. Doubtless they’ll bump into a Canadian backpacker somewhere in the 23rd Quadrant.
The show won't perish for lack of narrative tricks, traps and triggers. There are flashbacks reaching back five and 10 years, and there’s going to be bags of back-story action between the characters. Donner (Ron Livingston, previously the hard-drinking Captain Nixon from Band of Brothers) has a fraught relationship with geologist Zoe Barnes, as well as a difficult past with his alcoholic dad who wanted him to be a baseball player. Married astronauts Jen and Rollie Crane are now facing a six-year separation after Rollie had to quit Antares after developing a sudden heart murmur, while medical officer Evram Mintz has some ‘fessing up to do about his problems with the demon drink. And they have to cope with all this while the intensely irritating Paula Morales (right) runs round the ship delivering a live video commentary for all the folks back on earth.
There’s going to be front-story action too, with Donner finding himself dreaming prophetic dreams. And a slow fuse set to splutter throughout the series has been lit by whispers about a dark secret which hasn’t yet been revealed to the Antares crew. But rather than thrilling us with anticipation, all this is like looking at a 900-page legal textook and knowing that you have to memorise it for an exam next Tuesday.
The neurotic screwing around with time seems to have defeated the production designers, because while the main action supposedly takes place in 2052, things like clothes, furniture, digital cameras and even the ketchup bottles look suspiciously 2009-vintage, while pop music still hasn't progressed beyond Britney. The indie-rock tracks shoehorned into the soundtrack to add emotional colour might have worked on Grey’s Anatomy (also from Defying Gravity’s creator James Parriott), but they sound gratingly inappropriate in a futuristic space saga.
Most problematic of all is that Gravity can’t decide whether it’s flat-out sci-fi like Star Trek, or something more discursive and philosophical, like Solaris. But since they’ve saddled Donner with a voice-over where he utters sententious homilies like “we can find redemption in the simplest acts of humanity” or “being an astronaut is all about control…you don’t want surprises”, expect a slow crawl round the bus lane of the universe, with very few jokes.
Next episode of Defying Gravity is on BBC Two at 9pm, Thursday October 29
Add comment
more TV
Blue Lights Series 2, BBC One review - still our best cop show despite a slacker structure
The engaging Belfast cops are less tightly focused this time around
Baby Reindeer, Netflix review - a misery memoir disturbingly presented
Richard Gadd's double traumas are a difficult watch but ultimately inspiring
Anthracite, Netflix review - murderous mysteries in the French Alps
Who can unravel the ghastly secrets of the town of Lévionna?
Ripley, Netflix review - Highsmith's horribly fascinating sociopath adrift in a sea of noir
Its black and white cinematography is striking, but eventually wearying
Scoop, Netflix review - revisiting a Right Royal nightmare
Gripping dramatisation of Newsnight's fateful Prince Andrew interview
RuPaul’s Drag Race UK vs the World Season 2, BBC Three review - fun, friendship and big talents
Worthy and lovable winners (no spoilers) as the best stay the course
This Town, BBC One review - lurid melodrama in Eighties Brummieland
Steven Knight revisits his Midlands roots, with implausible consequences
Passenger, ITV review - who are they trying to kid?
Andrew Buchan's screenwriting debut leads us nowhere
3 Body Problem, Netflix review - life, the universe and everything (and a bit more)
Mind-blowing adaptation of Liu Cixin's novel from the makers of 'Game of Thrones'
Manhunt, Apple TV+ review - all the President's men
Tobias Menzies and Anthony Boyle go head to head in historical crime drama
The Gentlemen, Netflix review - Guy Ritchie's further adventures in Geezerworld
Riotous assembly of toffs, gangsters, travellers, rogues and misfits
Oscars 2024: politics aplenty but few surprises as 'Oppenheimer' dominates
Christopher Nolan biopic wins big in a ceremony defined by a pink-clad Ryan Gosling and Donald Trump seeing red
Comments
...