mon 22/07/2024

Bach Unwrapped, Blaze, La Nuova Musica, Bates, Kings Place | reviews, news & interviews

Bach Unwrapped, Blaze, La Nuova Musica, Bates, Kings Place

Bach Unwrapped, Blaze, La Nuova Musica, Bates, Kings Place

Not quite enough undiluted Johann Sebastian in a problematic evening

Members of La Nuova Musica with director David Bates (seated centre)Graeme Robertson

Faced with yet another world premiere from his friends in the Borodin Quartet, Shostakovich severely asked them whether they’d yet played all of Haydn’s quartets (they hadn’t). As a listener, I feel the same about Bach’s cantatas. Whether or not a lifetime will be enough to catch each of these varied and ever surprising little miracles in the flesh, Kings Place’s Bach Unwrapped series includes a chance to hear nearly 30 of the 200 from seven different ensembles in less than a year.

Unfortunately it looks as if I drew the short straw at the end of the first four concerts.

There was only one problem about the programming, which sacrificed undiminished genius with curiosity value in the second half. Two more cantatas might have stood in for Bach’s adaptation of Pergolesi’s famous Stabat Mater as Psalm 51 – a pretty piece, of course, and not without its own rhythmic novelties, but still quite a descent from JSB’s personal level. In fact it received the most unblemished performance, spirited countertenor Robin Blaze (pictured below by Dorothea Heise) blending in musicianly harmony with clean, bright soprano Helen-Jane Howells. It was probably not her fault if Luther's translation didn’t seem to sit too meaningfully on top of the original Latin-set lines.

Robin BlazeHere, too, the strings of La Nuova Musica danced along guttily. But I wonder if they would have done so just the same on their own without the over-large gestures of director David Bates. Surely, for example, players’ entries don’t need to be semaphored with urgent outstretched arm; they know when to come in. Experience should teach this young conductor that less is more, that what you see from him is what you ought to hear. The more energetic passages were all the better for lively accenting, but the slow movement of the Concerto in C minor adapted for violin and oboe should coast over the barlines and never feel like a slow waltz rhythm in every bar, and the most wonderful of the arias in the Cantata Gott soll allein mein Herze haben, “Stirb in mir”, unearthly-strange as its most outlandish progressions sounded, needed more long-term winsomeness, too.

Not that Blaze didn’t phrase eloquently and with his usual impeccable musical instincts, even if this was still a reminder that time marches on and robs most countertenors of some of their short-lived bloom all too soon. Stage management was a real obstacle here, though: from stalls left our soloist, surely set too far back, was completely obscured by Bates standing at the harpsichord. Oboist Joel Raymond needed to be further forward, too, in the concerto: the period instrument can sound muddy in its middle range, unnaturally loud at either end, and Raymond seemed to be having some trouble with rounding off even some of the shorter lines.

Other imprecisions from chamber organ in the cantata and, very briefly, the whole ensemble in the Overture to the First Orchestral Suite also detracted from the kind of perfection we perhaps too readily take for granted in groups such as this. Not entirely, then, the kind of New Year wake-up call we expect from Bach; no "asperging with hyssop", as the translation of Psalm 51 in the programme had it, on this occasion.

Experience should teach director David Bates that less is more, that what you see from him is what you ought to hear


Editor Rating: 
Average: 3 (1 vote)

Share this article


I'm not at all clear why a Bach cantata should require a conductor at all. Surely a job for the leader or the harpsichord-player. And, since you mention Haydn quartets: why do young quartets always programme their performance first in concerts. Did noone tell them that Haydn is more elusive than most. Best tackled when warmed up!

I have been going to concerts for over 30 years ( but would not consider myself a music expert). However I found the combination of Robin Blaze and Helen - Jane Howells absolutely divine in the 2nd half. Both had great presence on stage, a sense of joy and an immense love of the music. Both really have God given gifts. I have followed Robin Blaze's career for years and having met a fair few performers can honestly say he was an absolute joy to meet. Here is to Tokyo with him and the Bach Collegium. Wow factor and will be out of this world. Thanks to all of you for a wonderful evening.

Add comment

Subscribe to

Thank you for continuing to read our work on For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters