thu 12/12/2024

Symphony, BBC Four | reviews, news & interviews

Symphony, BBC Four

Symphony, BBC Four

Grand tour of 'the pinnacle of compositional technique' begins with a flourish

Ironic, erudite, clubbable... presenter Simon Russell Beale surveys the symphonic universe

Having blazed a trail through choral music, Simon Russell Beale now focuses his attentions on the symphony in this new four-part series. At last able to put aside the mind-games and chicanery of his role as Home Secretary William Towers in Spooks (RIP), Beale emerged as an engaging and enthusiastic host in this opening episode.

He wore his erudition with an ironic twinkle as he toured the garrets and palaces of Europe on the trail of Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven. He seemed especially to relish being able to bob about in a yacht off Dover, in emulation of Haydn's queasy cross-Channel voyage to Blighty in 1791.

Nor was Beale averse to the occasional grand orchestral flourish of his own. In this series, we would learn - he declared, somewhat resembling a one-man horn section accompanied by kettledrums and gongs - how the symphony emerged from the world of aristocratic privilege, how it "accompanied the rise of nations and the fall of empires", how it "taught the orchestra how to speak", how it soundtracked both liberty and totalitarianism... Blimey. All of human, and superhuman, life will be here. (Conductor Sir Mark Elder on the podium, pictured above.)

But it all began most agreeably with Joseph Haydn, the so-called "father of the symphony", who was what the poet John Dryden might have described as "a perpetual fountain of good sense". Wise, witty and humane, Haydn had taken full advantage of the private orchestra and splendid music room supplied by his patron, Prince Nikolaus Esterhazy, to experiment freely with orchestral effects and musical structures. When he came to London after Nikolaus's death, he was hailed as "the first ever bona-fide musical superstar", according to our presenter, and his string of London symphonies are counted among his finest, as well as being considered the vital platform for future symphonic developments.

But you don't have to take my word for it, or even Russell Beale's, because also on hand was conductor Sir Mark Elder, propelling the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment (pictured left) through brisk and vivid excerpts from some carefully selected works. Not least among these was Symphony No 98, in which Haydn rang some ingenious musical changes on the British national anthem, which could hardly help but be improved as a result.

Elder also supplied some informative commentary of his own. He was especially compelling when he explained how Haydn had developed the coherent four-movement symphony from the instrumental preludes that used to be played before opera performances in the 18th century. But though Haydn wrote 106 symphonies, the modest maestro was happy to admit that his young friend Mozart was "always my superior". He also taught the 22-year-old Beethoven, but would doubtless have concurred with Elder's observation that Beethoven's stunning Eroica Symphony, first performed in 1804, brought classical music to "the threshold of another age".

This was all wonderfully enjoyable stuff, taking a discursive voyage through a tumultuous period in European history to a soundtrack of glittering symphonic highlights. The clubbable Beale (pictured right in his Spooks heyday) even found time for a trip to Haydn's private herb garden, followed by a sybaritic sampling of Baroque cuisine (platter du jour was braised rabbit with dumplings and cherries).

The Symphony series is part of a month-long campaign across BBC Four and Radio 3 to explore the symphony in all its aspects, and it would have been difficult to make a friendlier or more welcoming film than this one, but it's still unlikely to convert hordes of unbelievers to the classical path. A question that continues to hang in the air is why was it natural for 18th or 19th-century audiences to apply themselves to a complex piece of music lasting 20, 30 or 40 minutes, while today many of us can barely concentrate for the duration of a three-minute pop song? Perhaps Elder will get stuck into that one later on.

Comments

I watched this having enjoyed the ‘Baroque’ series; however, I was aghast at the submerging of Simon’s delivery in a gratuitous exhibition of post- editing, an ego trip by the production room nerds subjecting us to a blur of subliminal images which added nothing to the prog and against which Simon valiantly fought –a bit like that prog ‘Distraction’. Things had improved by the time we got to Beethoven but then there was too little time for Haydn & Mozart due to his inclusion – van B needs a whole prog to himself. All in all, a disappointment.

I looked forward to this series....but in the end was absolutely AGHAST at how awful the first episode was. A huge opportunity to draw in the unconverted (as well as nourish the converted!) in focusing on a central element of the classical music corpus.....with a decent travel budget, the use of an orchestra, an enthusiastic presenter....and what did we get? A disaster. What a mess!! A bewildering mass of fast-moving images, rapid-fire location changes and fleeting visits to this or that symphony with seemingly no care for building a coherent overall narrative. What was the STORY, for God's sake?? I completely understand that these days fast-cutting is the norm, but without underlying substance this was just fast-cutting for the sake of it. Maybe things did improve when Beethoven came onto the scene as the previous post suggested, but by then I'd switched off....I was so wound up and angry. With classical music needing more than ever to make its case these days, this was a major opportunity utterly and embarrassingly missed. There are so many more things I could say....but I'm getting wound up again!

It was thoroughly enjoyable watching this entire series, however I was looking forward to the very last episode, being mainly interested in 20th and 21st century music. Where is the mention of Stravinsky, Arnold, Gorecki, Lutoslawski, Glass, Adams, etc.? I'd like to think it was because of the limit of four episodes, and of course it is vital to first talk about the creators of the symphony, but something tells me it is because of a prejudice against new music? I waited for the final episode, and what Beale would document about the 21st century, but I guess I should have expected less. Overall though, great if you're just interested in what happened hundreds years ago.

Add comment

The future of Arts Journalism

 

You can stop theartsdesk.com closing!

We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £33,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d

And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters