BBC Proms: Orchestre Philharmonique de Radio France, Chung/ Erben, Belcea Quartet

Two Proms deliver a Holy Trinity, from geriatric Brahms to spectral Schubert

by Igor ToronyilalicTuesday, 19 July 2011

Violinist Corina Belcea-Fisher: 'Impeccable in technique and delivery'

The Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost materialised yesterday. And I'm not talking about the transcendental appearance of the Holy Trinity of News International. I'm talking Proms. Last night's two saw a geriatric performance of the Brahms double, a brand spanking new way through an old Rite and a transfiguringly spectral invocation of Schubert's Quintet.

Buy

Recordings by Renaud and Gautier Capucon on Amazon

Explore topics

Share this article

...

Permalink Submitted by Brian (not verified) on Wed, 20/07/2011 - 10:00

One of my friends said years ago "Brahms should bounce". Chung's idea of Brahms was far too dull. What one admired in this performance was the unanimity of the Capuçon brothers, Gautier watching Renaud intently. As for the Rite, all the notes were there in the right order, but without any feeling for the subtext of the music. Yet another Proms Rite that hasn't reached the excellence of the Budapest Festival Orchestra under Iván Fischer in 2006!

...

Permalink Submitted by David N (not verified) on Wed, 20/07/2011 - 10:22

That's it in a nutshell, Brian: "Brahms should bounce". And dance, and cross the barlines. Jurowski knows what to do. So did Ashkenazy in a Prom many years back which took me by surprise in its treatment of the second subjects almost as ballet music. Brahms is NOT dull or academic!

...

Permalink Submitted by Devils Trill (not verified) on Wed, 20/07/2011 - 10:36

The performance of the Brahms was quite dull, and Chung's accompaniment didn't really match the spirit of the soloists (though I found their playing rather too emphatic). The Rite was good (though the brass fell into the same trap that Daniele Gatti's French orchestra did last year at the end of the first part). I heard a stunningly good Rite played by Dutoit and the RPO at the RFH a month or two ago, which set the bar very high and as good as this one was, the Dutoit Rite was rather too fresh in my memory. The Belcea Schubert was outstanding, really making the case that we can listen to these works in different ways in unusual venues.

Add comment

more Classical music

Fröst, Philharmonia, Lazarova, Kuusisto, Southbank Centre review - congenial new works complemented by live-wire classics Two concerts revolving around composer Anna Clyne offer plenty of other surprises

First Person: Donatella Flick on why the conducting competition in her name is needed more than ever The 17th Donatella Flick LSO Conducting Competition reaches its final tonight

The Chevalier, St Martin-in-the-Fields review - virtuoso journey into a shamefully neglected past Music is the star in this retelling of the remarkable life of black composer Joseph Bologne

First Person: Anna Clyne on composing collaborations, not battles, in her latest concertos UK premiere of 'Weathered' for clarinettist Martin Fröst is among a series of new works

Osborne, RSNO, Chan, Usher Hall, Edinburgh - cinematic sweep and surging drama Farewell to a much-loved Principal Guest Conductor in powerful Clyne and Tchaikovsky

Amidon, Clayton, SCO, Kuusisto, Queen's Hall, Edinburgh review - profuse and outstanding musicianship The Finnish violinist and conductor steers an insightful and exciting trio of concerts

Axing the BBC Singers: four associated musicians on why it's so wrong Dame Sarah Connolly leads musical voices on the latest cultural vandalism

Mahler’s Third Symphony, Philharmonia, Paavo Järvi, RFH review - phosphorescent glow, depths only glimpsed Stylish conducting, classy playing, but no big emotions in the crucial finale

Bernstein's Mass, RNCM, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - a happening, a demo, an achievement Manchester premiere of extraordinary ‘theatre piece’ marks a special anniversary

Nonclassical: The Greenhouse Effect, Barbican Conservatory review - enjoyable freestyle happening Quirky musical responses to the climate crisis amid indoor greenery

Classical CDs: Goblins, tailors and an errant knight Art songs, piano miniatures and a reed quintet

St Mary’s Music School, RSNO, New, Usher Hall, Edinburgh review - a cornucopia of delights From talented young musicians to a concerto for artist and orchestra

Follow @theartsdesk