A Culture Show Special: The Books We Really Read, BBC Two

A Culture Show Special: The Books We Really Read, BBC Two | reviews, news & interviews

A Culture Show Special: The Books We Really Read, BBC Two

What the popular bestseller can teach the literary novel. Apparently

by Fisun GunerSaturday, 05 March 2011

Sue Perkins, a self-confessed 'literary snob' is fed up with 'plotless' literary novels

Unlike Sue Perkins, I’ve never sat on the Booker Prize judging panel. So I’ve never had the dubious pleasure of wading through 130-plus contemporary “literary” novels, of supremely variable quality, in a supremely short space of time (it’s approximately a novel a day, I’ve heard, given the allocated time). But still, I was left somewhat puzzled by the Culture Show special, The Books We Really Read, because Perkins – who was a Booker Prize judge in 2009 and is yet to recover from the experience – comes to a conclusion I found slightly odd.

Many “literary” writers who self-consciously think of themselves as literary writers, often just aren’t that good

Explore topics

Share this article

...

Permalink Submitted by Mike (not verified) on Tue, 08/03/2011 - 09:39

This review only seems to give half the story of the programme, which seemed to have been scripted by someone who was so hung-up on plot that the documentary tried to take Perkins on her own mini-Odyssey. She was dreadfully snobbish (in the sort of inverted self-deprecating way that showed she really meant it) about having read English at Oxford and judged the Booker at the start of the programme. I thought after a few minutes that the inevitable conclusion was that she would report on her own personal journey of partial conversion and redemption from her own high-mindedness about the trash she was going to investigate. And that's what we got. If you're going to criticise literary fiction then plot is a pretty tame thing to go for. Absence of a conventional plot or narrative is something of a badge of pride -- see the comments at the end of the 12 debut novelist programme about how only one book used third person omniscient narration. Like so many current documentaries you wonder why on earth we had to have this intrusive personality stamping their ego all over it. It really wasn't necessary.

Add comment

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

more TV

Sambre: Anatomy of a Crime, BBC Four review - satisfying novelistic retelling of a French true crime saga Compelling story of a rapist who hid in plain sight for 30 years

Kaos, Netflix review - playing fast and profuse with the Greek myths A rainbow of acting talent, but too many ideas thrown into the labyrinth

Slow Horses, Season 4, Apple TV+ review - Gary Oldman returns as the 'gross and inappropriate' Jackson Lamb Latest instalment of the Slough House saga exerts a vice-like grip

theartsdesk Q&A: David Morrissey on (among other things) the return of 'Sherwood' and 'Daddy Issues' Liverpool-born actor reflects on a journey from Everyman Theatre to film and TV stardom

Sherwood, Series 2, BBC One review - maybe time isn't such a great healer Gripping continuation of James Graham's Nottinghamshire saga

Freddie Flintoff: Field of Dreams on Tour, BBC One review - a passage to India with the Preston irregulars Cricket helps Fred overcome near-death experience

The Instigators, Apple TV+ review - Matt Damon and Casey Affleck are back on the Beantown beat Doug Liman's black-comedy thriller is lifted by its high-octane cast

Stevie Van Zandt: Disciple, Sky Documentaries review - the New Jersey rocker with many strings to his bow Bill Teck's film reveals that Van Zandt wasn't just Bruce Springsteen's right-hand man

Time Bandits, Apple TV+ review - larky expanded rerun of the Gilliam/Palin classic Taika Waititi and Jemaine Clement give children's sci-fi a human touch

Lady in the Lake, Apple TV+ review - a multi-layered Baltimore murder mystery Natalie Portman stars in screen adaptation of Laura Lippman's novel

The Jetty, BBC One review - lowlife in a Northern town Jenna Coleman stars in a dark tale of abuse and exploitation

The Turkish Detective, BBC Two review - a bad business in the Bosphorus Barbara Nadel's Inspector Ikmen novels reach the screen

Follow @theartsdesk