As You Like It / Hamlet, Shakespeare’s Globe review - ensemble emphasis sets a leaner style

There’s a distinct feeling of back to basics to this opening double bill at the Globe under the theatre’s new Artistic Director Michelle Terry. The elaborations (some would say gimmickry) of Emma Rice’s short tenure have been reined back, and a new concentration prevails.

This first presentation – two plays written around 1599, the year in which Shakespeare's original Globe opened: As You Like It was staged that year, Hamlet a little later – is built on a new approach to ensemble that draws on a broader casting base than usual.

That involved a gender-neutral approach (with a 50:50 gender ratio), and has made for a round-dozen company of versatile actors. They apparently rehearsed together – attending all rehearsals, regardless of appearance in any particular scene – over three months (considerably longer than usual). Federay Holmes and Elle While are jointly credited as directors for both shows, while Terry has spoken of “ownership” shared across the company.

Stature is as much of an issue in this 'As You Like It'  as gender

The big issue is, of course, how such an approach has come to fruit in the productions. Another question entirely, whether these are “sibling” pieces which gain something by playing alongside one another on the same day? Not significantly so on the latter, I think, though there’s certainly real interest in seeing how the pairings work across the two plays.

On the former, Terry’s taking on the title role in Hamlet hardly qualifies as a surprise at all. It’s in the already role-overlapping world of As You Like It (★★★) that readjustments of expectation come into the equation. There’s certainly a new dimension to Jack Laskey (channelling David Tennant) as he moves from Rosalind’s stiff Spanish court skirts to a new naturalness of gait as the youth Ganymede; it certainly makes the “counterfeit to be a man” injunction freshly piquant. Casting Bettrys Jones as Orlando rather fudges the gender question, however, since the role here has a tomboy element of compromise; he/she's an aspiring boy-hero throughout, whose slight stature emphasises an immaturity that barely develops.

Indeed, stature is as much of an issue here as gender, with Laskey’s Rosalind/Ganymede – “more than common tall” has never rung truer – towering over Jones’s diminutive Orlando, an unlikely pairing that adds considerable humour (pictured below: Bettrys Jones, Jack Laskey). But is the extra confusion engendered by adding another layer to the role disguise a step too far: it's now that of a man playing a woman pretending to be a man, who is wooing a man, who's all the time, of course, really a woman? Possibly, but there’s insight, too. Much simpler is Helen Schlesinger’s doubling of the two dukes, as able as the swiftness with which, on a stage virtually free of props (which minimises our sense of contrast), the action transfers from court to forest.Laskey looms tall over Rosalind’s bosom companion Celia, too. Casting D/deaf performer Nadia Nadarajah (also playing Guildenstern in Hamlet) in that role challenges expectations in a different way. There’s definite expressiveness, and initial comedy to Celia communicating with Rosalind and others in sign language, while some of the sense lost is offered by those with whom she is conversing (it also reveals how the Duke her father doesn’t communicate with her at all). But there's no getting away from an accruing loss of story context and development, not to mention Celia's rapier textual wit.

Designer Ellan Parry’s costumes have an ensemble quality too, spanning period to present day, and brought together from a range of sources (the Globe’s wardrobe reserves as well as items contributed, as in the theatre’s original day, by the players themselves). That gives the emotional conflicts and couplings of the down-to-earth forest natives a nicely contemporary context – almost, with the Welsh accents on display, a sense that we have dropped into Gavin and Stacey territory – into which Colin Hurley’s Touchstone fits fluently. He finds easy comradeship there with Pearce Quigley’s Jaques, lugubrious in black and complete with Russian philosopher beard, who gives his speeches an emphasised slow casualness (“Seven Ages of Man” begins mid-mouthful of banana).

Production-wise there could have been more comic touches like the flock of (human) sheep which accompanied the action’s move to Arden. The musically reinforced stag interlude starts up a growing ensemble haste, which concludes with Tanika Yearwood as Hymen in a scene that brings the spectacle to an ebullient conclusion, as well as offering the most elaborate stagecraft of the whole day.

The evening’s Hamlet (★★★★) felt considerably starker by comparison, as well as generally more conventional; this court is presided over by an all-too-solid regal pairing (pictured above: Helen Schlesinger as Gertrude, James Garnon as Claudius, with Bettrys Jones as a player), alongside Richard Katz who is winning, though hardly over-complicated, as Polonius. Michelle Terry's gender transposition proves more memorable than that of Bettrys Jones as Orlando, Hamlet’s slightness of youth accompanied here by a sense of flighty poetry that is brought home by a mid-play white-suited Pierrot costume: it might have seemed simply affected, but felt instead an effective interlude.

For this was a prince with as much a sense of “ecstasy” as of madness, whose soliloquies came over with an equal sense of real sincerity and colloquial, improvisatory freedom. Terry excelled in them, Hamlet’s agility emphasised too by an initial stiffness in Ophelia (Shubham Saraf), the result partly of costume. She began in another constricted court dress (if not as elaborate as the Velazquez riffs of As You Like It), which gave an attendant rigour of poise that lasted even into the simple black garb of madness.

The company of actors arrived straight from the present day, and the play-within-the-play, led by a jeans-clad Laskey (also a brisk Fortinbras) was a stand-out. Composer James Maloney was having fun with mysterious rumblings of the grave (moments relating to the Ghost), while jazz elements counterpointed the recurrent stern brass fanfares.

Both productions had moments which must have seemed better in concept than they did in execution: Hamlet seemed the more fully realised of the two, As You Like It perhaps yet to settle. For all the ensemble background to their creation, the central roles here (Terry as Hamlet, Laskey as Rosalind) rather defined both – and clarity of text, it's good to say, is back at the Globe. Co-directors Federay Holmes and Elle While prove that less is more (especially when you remember how inappropriate that “more” has occasionally been at the venue recently), though we can only guess quite what (and how) they contributed as directors in the standard sense when responsibilities were so shared. Under Terry’s inclusive helm, the Globe has already changed: there's more exploring to come before any new "face" reveals itself, but this bodes well.

• As You Like It and Hamlet at Shakespeare’s Globe to August 26
• Read more theatre reviews on theartsdesk