The Makropulos Case, English National Opera

Alden and Roocroft come together for a perfect, if nihilistic, night of opera

by Igor ToronyilalicTuesday, 21 September 2010

'Amanda Roocroft was incredible as Emilia Marty, both vocally and physically, capturing the fragility of this well-travelled soul as well as the mania'

Opera spends so much of its time killing off female protagonists that it's refreshing to come back to The Makropulos Case. In it Janáček, in one of his many moments of generosity, imagines what might happen if you allowed a woman not just to live but to live forever. The answer? They become a bloody nightmare.

This is as near to a perfect evening of opera as you are likely to get

Buy

Buy tickets for The Makropulos Case on seetickets.com

Explore topics

Share this article

...

Permalink Submitted by Catherine (not verified) on Tue, 21/09/2010 - 14:36

That's a fun opening paragraph. But I thought that one of the points of this Alden production is that EM is more sinned against by unscrupulous men than sinning: quite a feminist tract going on here. And is it not the very opposite of nihilistic, the final message - that human life only has value when lived within its natural limits? That's very liberating, surely. Anyway, can't wait to see it again.

...

Permalink Submitted by Catherine (not verified) on Tue, 28/09/2010 - 10:18

So now I have, and what's all the fuss about the 'final terrifying idea'? I won't say what it is either, but the point is that in both the music and the text, the manuscript has to burn. It's a failure of Janacek's take on the piece not to acknowledge that.

Add comment

more Opera

Fidelio, Garsington Opera review - heart of darkness, light-filled liberation Fine singers equalled by Philharmonia soloists in revelatory chamber-music Beethoven

Eavesdropping on Rattle, the LSO and Bartók’s Bluebeard Ahead of the London Symphony Orchestra’s streaming next month, a privileged preview

La bohème, Scottish Opera – pandemic Puccini Top-quality cast and players put on a potted version in a parking lot

The Royal Opera: Live in Concert review - Italianate fizz with a patch of flatness A glorious orchestra and chorus under their inspiring music director are back in style

Sāvitri, Lauderdale House review - death and life in a Highgate garden Hampstead Garden Opera works a little miracle with Holst's mystical music-drama

The Encore, Opera Holland Park review - stylish return for a squad of old friends A moving and delightful al fresco feast of opera favourites

Heart's Delight, Opera Holland Park review - a classy hour of operetta pops Five fine singers and a small orchestra deliver hits at a high level

Moses und Aron, Komische Oper Berlin, OperaVision review – complex and powerful memorial Schoenberg’s opera of unanswerable questions proves a fitting Holocaust epitaph

Elektra, Salzburg Festival, Arte review - distancing, but not in the physical sense Cold, analytical Strauss from Franz Welser-Möst and an odd array of performing styles

First Person: Antonia Bain on directing a short kitchen opera for film Scottish Opera's digital content producer on making 'The Narcissistic Fish'

Classical music/Opera direct to home 19 – and two before a live audience Finally, you can be in the room, or space, where it happens in two east London venues

The Opera Story: Episodes review - whimsical takes on lockdown life Young London company offers snapshots of contemporary living

Follow @theartsdesk