BBC National Orchestra of Wales, Hoddinott Hall, Cardiff

Noisy Vaughan Williams symphony is a Royal College of Music period piece

by Stephen WalshThursday, 12 May 2011

David Atherton: Excellent, undemonstrativeAskonas Holt

It’s a neat-sounding idea for a concert: a sequence of works composed in the year the previous composer died. Neat, but not necessarily revealing. This one started with Elgar’s Cockaigne, composed – symbolically, I assume – in 1900, and ended with Vaughan Williams’s Fourth Symphony, completed in 1934, the year of Elgar’s death. In between came Britten’s Nocturne, written in VW’s last year, 1958. With a little more time, they might have added Birtwistle’s Melancolia (1976, Britten), and left everyone completely bemused.

Their playing had all the necessary impact, and the lady next to me nearly jumped out of her skin on a couple of occasions

Explore topics

Share this article

...

Permalink Submitted by David N (not verified) on Thu, 12/05/2011 - 08:07

Can't agree with that judgment of Vaughan Williams's Fourth. Sometimes dissonance can be exultant, as in Bartok's Fourth String Quartet, and though this symphony isn't perhaps quite on that level, it always gives me a buzz when I hear it. And are performances so frequent that we can just rule it out? Ah well, your opinion, I guess.

...

Permalink Submitted by David Atherton (not verified) on Thu, 12/05/2011 - 19:06

I make it a point of never responding to reviews of my performances and I'm certainly not going to object to Stephen's thoughtful piece. However, when I'm misquoted, as happened in the spoken introduction, I must reply. What I actually said was that, "within VW's output, the harmonic language used by the composer was forward-looking". Compare Syms 1-3. True, the last movement makes one wish that he'd never heard of fugato and the musical ideas are somewhat paltry; nevertheless I feel it is a much stronger work than is suggested above.

Add comment

The future of Arts Journalism

You can stop theartsdesk.com closing!

We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £49,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d

And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

more Classical music

BBC Proms: Batsashvili, BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra, Ryan Wigglesworth review - grief and glory Subdued Mozart yields to blazing Bruckner

Classical CDs: Hens, Hamburg and handmaids An unsung French conductor boxed up, plus Argentinian string quartets and baroque keyboard music

BBC Proms: McCarthy, Bournemouth SO, Wigglesworth review - spring-heeled variety A Ravel concerto and a Walton symphony with depth but huge entertainment value

BBC Proms: First Night, Batiashvili, BBCSO, Oramo review - glorious Vaughan Williams Spirited festival opener is crowned with little-heard choral epic

Interview: Quinteto Astor Piazzolla on playing in London and why Mick Jagger's a fan Music Director Julián Vat and pianist Matias Feigin compare notes on Piazzolla

theartsdesk at the Ravenna Festival 2025 - Cervantes, Beethoven and Byron transfigured Muti revitalised by young musicians, and a three-year theatre project reaches completion

Classical CDs: Bells, birdsong and braggadocio British contemporary music, percussive piano concertos and a talented baritone sings Mozart

Siglo de Oro, Wigmore Hall review - electronic Lamentations and Trojan tragedy Committed and intense performance of a newly-commissioned oratorio

Alfred Brendel 1931-2025 - a personal tribute A master of feeling and intellect

Aldeburgh Festival, Weekend 2 review - nine premieres, three young ensembles - and Allan Clayton A solstice sunrise swim crowned the best of times at this phoenix of a festival

Schubertiade 3 at the Ragged Music Festival, Mile End review - five great musicians keep spirits soaring Kolesnikov, Tsoy, Leonskaja, Ibragimova and Hecker in spellbinding performances

Immersive Night Music Show, Makita, Londinium Ensemble, World Heart Beat Embassy Gardens - multimedia musings on a midsummer night This intriguing musical/visual collaboration was best when it was boldest

Follow @theartsdesk