wed 24/07/2024

Paul Lewis/Hyeyoon Park, Benjamin Grosvenor, Wigmore Hall online/BBC Radio 3 review - tranquil Schubert, fiery Franck | reviews, news & interviews

Paul Lewis/Hyeyoon Park, Benjamin Grosvenor, Wigmore Hall online/BBC Radio 3 review - tranquil Schubert, fiery Franck

Paul Lewis/Hyeyoon Park, Benjamin Grosvenor, Wigmore Hall online/BBC Radio 3 review - tranquil Schubert, fiery Franck

Locked-down stars take to an empty Wigmore Hall with fervour and equanimity

Paul Lewis: soaring in SchubertAll mages taken from Wigmore Hall filming

The Wigmore Hall’s triumphant series of lockdown lunchtime concerts by the finest of local recitalists is not without an audience; it’s just that the performers can’t see them.

Conversely, online viewers can watch the artists closely enough to see what fingering pianists choose for the awkward passages, and the sound quality is remarkably fine - though may also depend on your computer or smartphone (I heard Steven Isserlis’s recital the other day on my phone from the middle of Richmond Park). It’s welcome, as it’s all we have at present, but I, for one, refuse to accept that bone-chilling expression “the new normal”. There is nothing normal about this.

Yesterday, however, Paul Lewis rose to the occasion magnificently in a programme of fantasy-sonatas that was singularly well chosen (★★★★). Sporting somewhat more than designer stubble, plus music on an iPad balanced inside the piano, Lewis sounded entirely at home, performing as if thinking aloud in this solitary splendour. In Beethoven’s Op. 27 No. 2, the "Moonlight", marked 'quasi una fantasia', he offered a splendid sense of contrast between the three movements, each benefitting from both empathy and strong characterisation. The finale was the only storm and stress in the programme and Lewis made the most of it. Paul Lewis at the Wigmore HallYet it was the Schubert G major "Fantasy Sonata" D894 in which he truly soared, capturing both the inwardness and the equanimity of Schubert in his most generous, heavenly-length mode. With Lieder-like, eloquent phrases, glowing legatos and heart-stopping nuances at those magical switches from minor to major, this was a near-ideal performance of the perfect work for peaceful isolation, melting radiantly into an ineffable conclusion. As encore he offered Beethoven’s Bagatelle Op. 126 No. 5 - tender, calm and just a tad nostalgic.

The inner tranquility of Lewis’s playing was a very different story from the fireworks presented the day before by the young violin and piano duo of Hyeyoon Park and Benjamin Grosvenor (though it's ★★★★ for them too). Their programme paired Szymanowski’s Mythes and Franck’s blockbuster Sonata in A major: this choice works very well, with just the right amount of differences and similarities - though it’s slightly dangerous territory, dominated hitherto by an everybody’s-favourite classic recording made in the early 1980s by the Polish violinist Kaja Danczowska with her compatriot Krystian Zimerman. Park and GrosvenorPark and Grosvenor are as well suited to one another as to their choice of repertoire, their duo wholly and apparently effortlessly in sympathy. The Szymanowski - three pieces written during World War I, in which the composer is alternately at his most sensual and occasionally his most irritating - gave Park the chance to shine in a range of iridescent colours. Her refinement of tone in "The Fountain of Arethusa" blossomed out into a rainbowed intensity, and the piping effects in "Dryads and Pan'" which are treacherous high harmonics, were flawlessly projected. At the piano Grosvenor made light and supple work of Szymanowski’s complex writing. The Franck Sonata, an altogether more forthright and full-blooded work - it was the composer’s wedding gift to the great violinist Eugène Ysaÿe, with a finale full of pealing bells - benefitted from the performers’ close ensemble and unanimity of approach, although an impression of excess tension slightly interfered at times with its emotional sweep. This, of all violin sonatas, can use the warmth of a live audience feeding energy back to the musicians. 

Add comment

Subscribe to

Thank you for continuing to read our work on For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters