mon 22/04/2024

The 7 39, BBC One | reviews, news & interviews

The 7.39, BBC One

The 7.39, BBC One

David Nicholls's pretty suburbanites fail to smoulder convincingly

Strangers from a train: Sheridan Smith and David Morrissey play commuters Sally and Carl

There are times us northerners watch your typical London-set big-budget BBC drama and think, well, this really is another world. Whether it’s the two-hour commutes or the estate agencies where there is so much business that nobody has time to sit and watch cat videos on YouTube, there’s little about the world of The 7.39 familiar to those of us lacking three-bedroom semi-detached suburbia and a job in the City.

That said, there’s probably little about David Nicholls’ vision of London that seems familiar to those who live and work in the capital either. As in the screenwriter’s novel-turned-film One Day, London here is full of used book markets and flattering sunlight; lingering glances and slow-motion lovemaking involving extremely attractive people and it somehow not being creepy for the man who insulted you on the train the day before to show up the next day with a classic novel similar to the one you're reading and a need for conversation.

Nicholls has never been one for trite, happy endings

David Morrissey and Sheridan Smith were the star-crossed commuters brought together on, you guessed it, the 7.39 train from their nameless home town into Waterloo. He, Carl, was a harried estate agent and married father of two, a 12-year veteran of the rush hour and skilled in the art of finding a vacant seat; she, Sally, was the manager of a London gym recently transplanted to the countryside, second-time-around engaged to a bodybuilding sex pest played by Nineties heartthrob Sean Maguire. One fateful Monday morning the two crossed words over the last seat in a crowded carriage, a few weeks later all the tasteful camera flares in the world couldn’t hide how often they were at it in a number of London hotel rooms that got progressively less classy as their affair rumbled on.

While it was obvious from the start that we were supposed to find the blossoming relationship between the pair romantic - how else to sustain two hours of drama about very little else? - the lack of spark between the two ordinarily magnificent leads posed a bit of a problem during those whispered conversations in the vestibule by the buffet car, while getting to know each other in Sally’s gym or while wrestling with twin single beds during an awkward first night together in a hotel, necessitated by a train strike leaving the two characters stranded together in central London overnight.

Olivia Coleman as Maggie in The 7.39It’s particularly hard to sympathise with Morrissey’s character: his wife Maggie (Olivia Colman, pictured right, occupying the only role with any dignity) is patient and loving with a wry sense of humour, and reserves so limitless for the couple’s aspiring actor son and brat of a daughter that when she reveals she does in fact have a job too it’s pretty surprising. He’s also the sort of character who’d buy the aforementioned book and spend an entire commute gazing at a near-perfect stranger while she is sleeping, and yet will not offer to walk her home the night that they both miss the train through drinking and don’t arrive back until 1am.

Of course, Nicholls has never been one for trite, happy endings: the second part of the drama, in which Carl and Sally had to face up to the realities of their affair and the effect that its reveal would have on their loved ones, was both more interesting and more believable than the first. Again, however, it’s a typically understated performance from Colman that holds the story together and provides its most realistic moments.

The lack of spark between the two ordinarily magnificent leads posed a bit of a problem


Editor Rating: 
Average: 2 (1 vote)

Share this article


Guess I must have watched a different version to the one you watched. Or perhaps the fact that, in the past, I have almost been a male version of "Maggie" proved more poignant and meaningful for me. Whilst at times a little too close to home, I did enjoy it & thought it very well acted & believable throughout. Not sure the north/south divide has anything to do with it though!

I loved this programme and thought the actors were brilliant !

Not a north/south divide - a City of London/everywhere else divide, which I was reminded of again reading the FT this morning. The prospect of finding lo... er, lust on my five minute sardinesque commute into Glasgow of a morning seems utterly fantastical.

But I'm really sorry to hear about your experience, while at the same time finding it interesting that our real-life perspectives possibly clouded our reaction to the drama. It's all too easy to take the p1ss if you haven't been there yourself, I guess.

I enjoyed The 739, being a fan of both David Morrissey and Sheridan Smith. I thought it was a strange ending though, who was the man with Sally and the baby? It didn't look like Ryan! The only north/south divide was the fact that both stars are northerners yet for some reason it was set down south!

Er, that was the whole point. She has obviously after 2 years moved on and met someone more appropriate for her and had a child. Of course this wasn't Ryan. Everything worked out as both originally wanted their lives to be like.

Add comment


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters