thu 25/07/2024

The Miners' Strike and Me, ITV | reviews, news & interviews

The Miners' Strike and Me, ITV

The Miners' Strike and Me, ITV

After 30 years, the battle lines are still clearly drawn

NUM President Arthur Scargill exchanges pleasantries with the police

Thirty years ago this month, the National Coal Board announced the closure of 20 pits that were deemed "uneconomic", a decision which would incur the loss of 20,000 jobs. Arthur Scargill, president of the National Union of Mineworkers, responded by calling a strike that would become the longest industrial dispute in British history. It was also probably the most bitter, as the recollections of the former miners and their wives assembled for this documentary painfully demonstrated.

Even with its furry low-definition quality, the 1980s news footage of the striking miners and their clashes with the police was still petrifying in its rawness. Scenes of the pitched battle at the Orgreave coking plant in June 1984 were reminiscent of some medieval campaign, as police on horseback galloped out from the lines of officers barricaded behind long riot shields, flailing with their batons at anybody within reach. Just add a few ranks of archers and you'd have had Agincourt (miners' wives Carol Greathead and Maureen Douglas, pictured below).

It strains credibility that the British state was willing to unleash this much force on its own citizens, more or less unarmed even if they were chucking rocks at the rozzers, and it's amazing that nobody died. Clips of strike veterans whooping with joy at the death of Margaret Thatcher last year was an unedifying reminder of the unbridgeable chasm of loathing that still remains.

Michael Heseltine, secretary of state in the Conservative government at the time, was resolutely unapologetic, maintaining that the struggle between over-mighty unions and their threat to an elected government was an issue that "had to be faced, and there was no nice way to do it." The existential nature of the confrontation is difficult to grasp now, in our era of bland political micro-management kept as far away as possible from meddlesome voters.

The film didn't aim to impart retrospective political spin, but merely allowed the individual voices to be heard. The stories of communities destroyed and families barely able to feed themselves during the winter of '84 were harrowing enough, but the most dismal aspect of the saga was the implacable hatred of diehard strikers for the men who continued to work. "Once a scab always a scab - the lowest of the low to me," as miner's wife Carol Greathead put it. Steven Whyles (pictured below), a veteran of Whitwell colliery in Derbyshire, described how his father, now in his eighties, still hadn't forgiven him, and wouldn't do so even on his death-bed - "I'll call him a bloody scab and then I'll die," he said.

This Sicilian-style feuding was enough to chill the blood, but there was at least one man capable of taking a longer view. "We're not on this earth long, in reality," said Jimmy Johnson, a miner from Easington in Durham. "Move on. Get rid of your anger and find something else to get stuck into, because it's 30 years." I wonder how many will listen to him.

The 1980s news footage of the striking miners and their clashes with the police was still petrifying in its rawness


Editor Rating: 
Average: 4 (1 vote)

Share this article


The question was ( and is) should the mining industry - naturally in decline - have been maintained regardless of cost, as the miners union wanted? Of course not. There is no reason to take the other view unless the aim was to sink into the hopeless and drab inefficiency of the communist world. As Mr Scargill wanted, and used force to insist on his view. Should that force have been allowed to suceed? In fact the real benefits were to the coal owners who were bought out by the Attlee government before the decline began. Had they taken the losses, another advantage would have been that the industry would have declined gradually over time, rather than suddenly when the dangerous aims of the union had to be challenged

And I should have added that someone did die - a working miner was being driven to work in a taxi when a concrete block was dropped on the car from a bridge' killing him or the driver.

Add comment

Subscribe to

Thank you for continuing to read our work on For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a gift subscription?


Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters