sun 01/12/2024

Tubular Bells, The Charles Hazlewood All Stars, St George's Bristol | reviews, news & interviews

Tubular Bells, The Charles Hazlewood All Stars, St George's Bristol

Tubular Bells, The Charles Hazlewood All Stars, St George's Bristol

A classic of the 1970s provides an ear-opening lesson in Minimalism

Charles Hazlewood with one of his All Stars, Will Gregory from Goldfrapp

Tubular Bells, the first half of which is being currently revived as a live piece in the UK, sold between 15 and 17 million units worldwide. Quite apart from the work’s innocence being co-opted and made spooky in William Friedkin's The Exorcist, there was something about Mike Oldfield’s first stab at quasi-symphonic rock which seduced the music-consuming public.

Borrowing the repeated motifs of Minimalism – most specifically Terry Riley’s Rainbow in Curved Air – and similarly cyclical tropes that made Ravel’s Bolero and Grieg’s Peer Gynt so audience-grabbing, Tubular Bells wallowed in cliché but also broke new ground: this was one of the first examples of a musician recording most of the tracks himself – guitars, keyboards and percussion – but the mostly instrumental piece’s scale, spread over two sides of an LP, was also innovative, in pop or rock at least.

I am not sure whether to feel pride or shame but I played a part in the piece’s success. I had met Richard Branson – who signed Oldfield to his new Virgin label after hearing his demos – in 1967, when we were both involved in student journalism. He contacted me again in 1973 as he was about to launch his first release – Tubular Bells (pictured right). I was by then working on Second House, a fairly wild Saturday-night arts programme on BBC Two. The show was distinguished by a shambolic and knife-edge sense of experiment: performance artist Stuart Brisley lying in a bath of offal would be followed by a performance of David Bedford’s piece “With 100 Kazoos”, a cacophonous audience participation effort and the Mike Westbrook Band paired with Henry Woolf doing brilliant political satire.

I heard the Mike Oldfield piece and imagined a live version in the studio. Second House’s execs agreed, and Mike Oldfield brought along Mick Taylor of The Stones, Steve Hillage, Fred Frith, Mike Ratledge, David Bedford, Pierre Moerlein and other musicians associated with the label and the early 1970s avant-garde. Director Tony Staveacre, noted for his imaginative multi-camera studio work, visualised the piece beautifully, responding sensitively to the beguiling fluidity of the repeated motifs and the piece’s hallmark moments of drama.

The live version was presented soon afterwards at London's Queen Elizabeth Hall, to which Charles Hazlewood and his All Stars will return with the iconic piece on 6 December. Hazlewood regularly works with Will Gregory of Goldfrapp and Adrian Utley of Portishead, the duo who wrote a stunning new soundtrack for Dreyer’s The Passion of Joan of Arc. A few months ago, they put together two concerts celebrating the music of Terry Riley. It was Adrian Utley, looking for another similar collaborative project, who came across the BBC Two version of Tubular Bells and suggested it to Hazlewood. “When I had finished rolling around the floor laughing,” the conductor says, “I thought, why not? It does rumble on as one of the distinct parts of the UK’s musical DNA.”

 

Hazlewood is too young to have witnessed Tubular Bells when it first came out: “I thought of it as something that geeks listened to, the people who were nuts about Rush and early Genesis, all the things I sneered at, or guys who would chin on about which turntable they were using or what woofers were in their speakers.” Although people like to think of it as a Minimalist piece, he adds, “It isn’t really, it just wears some of the clothes of Minimalism. It’s incredibly cheesy, with some fairly execrable sections in it, bits which, to be fair to Oldfield, he’d created when he was a schoolboy. But once I’d seen the live version, which was quite different from Oldfield’s multi-tracking, I was convinced.” 

Mike Oldfield performs Tubular Bells

The piece needs to be seen in context, as a product of early-1970s British soft psychedelic whimsy, with a childlike and loony innocence also found in early Pink Floyd, The Incredible String Band and Kevin Ayers’s The Whole World – a band which included Mike Oldfield in its early days, as well as David Bedford. Oldfield was rooted in folk: he had started out in an acoustic duo with his sister Sally and there are plenty of appealing but inevitably generic references to a nostalgic English pastoral style, which colours some 20th-century classics as well as the less protest-driven end of the folk revival. Tubular Bells spoke to the people who, in the early 1970s, longed for the innocence of childhood and dreamed of "going back to the country", a recurring theme in our island’s cultural history, and one which undoubtedly has universal appeal.

Hazlewood is a populariser who embraces the audience in a way that turned the evening into something much more lively than an ordinary concert

For last Friday's Bristol performance, which will be repeated next month in London and Gateshead, Charles Hazlewood put together a brilliantly conceived programme, both didactic and entertaining. Tubular Bells was top of the bill, preceded by three pieces that put it into the context of Minimalism. Hazlewood is both teacher and preacher – he would make the perfect salesman – and he manages to make complex musical matters sound simple, dosing his articulate exposition with humour and a great deal of boyish charm. He is a populariser who really knows his stuff and he embraced the audience in a way that turned the evening into something much more lively than an ordinary concert. 

 

“Rainbow in Curved Air”, the evening’s opening piece, was played by an ensemble that included Adrian Utley (pictured below left), Will Gregory, Graham Fitkin, Ruth Wall and others. Hazlewood describes it as “the aural equivalent of climbing inside a giant lava lamp”, and as the organ loops swirled away, coming and going, Riley’s salvo against the conventions of goal-orientated narrative music took its hypnotic hold. The Steve Reich that followed, “Four Organs”, went one step further in the musical mantra stakes, repeating and stretching a chord many times over 15 minutes.

The Farfisa organs were kept in order by a strict and continuous beat played out on the maracas – heroically, considering the length of the piece – by percussionist Joby Burgess. He never once faltered and demonstrated exceptional physical stamina while manifesting the near-ecstasy that this trance-like pulse was creating. At a Carnegie Hall performance in the late 1960s, the audience couldn’t bear it and fights broke out. A woman walked up to the front of the hall and banged her head on the edge of the stage screaming for the piece to stop. In Bristol the Minimalist-friendly crowd, in characteristically laid-back West Country mode, lapped it up, listening with rapt attention and clearly enjoying the piece’s daring focus on the here and now.

Ruth Wall followed with another Reich piece, “Piano Phase”, originally for two keyboards but reworked for her own instrument, the harp. In a piece that weaves together two voices that start out with the same simple phrase in unison and are gradually pulled apart by a progressive offset, in a Minimalist take on the canon, she literally played with her recorded alter ego. The magical effect was somewhat spoilt by gremlins in the PA, and the filigree sound of intertwined harp sounds, as if a cascade of water were being deconstructed, was unfortunately marred by distortion.

The fun (and anxiety) the musicians were clearly experiencing was contagious

Originally presented at 1am in the rain at Glastonbury earlier this year, the Charles Hazlewood All Stars’ version of Tubular Bells – transcribed with some difficulty from the BBC Two recording – closed the evening. In his introduction, Hazlewood apologised for the piece’s shortcomings while acknowledging the nation’s debt to this iconic piece of 1970s prog rock. Some of the performance was halting - there were some obvious mistakes - but the piece was enhanced by the cliffhanging uncertainty of a live performance: the constituent elements of Oldfield’s piece are ridiculously simple while the structure is more intricate and unpredictable. The fun (and anxiety) the musicians were clearly experiencing was contagious, and the audience went happily along with playing that may not have been note-perfect but displayed a heartfelt engagement with the material which avoided the irony that would have robbed this less-than-perfect piece of the undeniable charm that has made it a classic.

The finale, that originally starred Viv Stanshall announcing with appropriate mock-pomp the instruments in the band, featured, rather appropriately, Tony Staveacre, the original director of the TV version that had inspired Adrian Utley and convinced Hazlewood in the first place. As the piece climbed, with echoes of Grieg’s Peer Gynt, to a finale that hovered between irony and cheese, he gave the part just the right upper-class stentorian tone. As the evening closed, not only had the audience revisited the soundtrack of a bygone era – and one of its signature horror flicks - but heard just how it fitted into the much more rigorous universe of Minimalism. Hats off to Hazlewood and his friends for producing an evening’s superb entertainment that was both thought-provoking and fun.

  • The Charles Hazlewood All Stars play Tubular Bells at the QEH on 6 December and The Sage, Gateshead, on 7 December

Comments

Well, I've never heard of this guy, so I don't know much about his own creativity, but to make such comments about TB is not only arrogant, but shows some clear gaps in his musical education. Sounds like a pretentious hack to me.

I don't like Jean-Michel Jarre's Oxygéne, so clearly the thing to do is tour my own version of it, apologising to audiences for how crap it is and then get fawning articles articles written about me. I'll get started on that right now.

Bit unfair how the article apologetically discusses the album. Mike's music has always had this negative patronising discussion thrown at it. It's a shame that it is always Tubular Bells gets the lions share of new reworkings. Most annoying is the inclusion of a video clip from tubular bells III which the writer is apparently confusing with the original?

I didn't confuse the original with Tubular Bells III, that was put in by one of the editorial people at TAD, and you're quite right, it shouldn't be there. I will get it replaced with the YouTube clip of the original BBC version that I produced

I went to the concert at the QEH in London last night - and I must say I was deeply disappointed by the performance of Tubular Bells. Firstly, they only played part 1, whilst advertising the whole work. This is just cheating the public, especially since part 2 contains some of the sections most obviously influenced by (and showing more strict adherence to) the minimalist movement. Far worse though, was the fact that the ensemble had prefaced Tubular Bells with some clearly expert and detailed performances of music by Terry Reilly and Steve Reich. Harp Phase was particularly impressive and hypnotic. There was also an impressive array of original vintage organs and synthesizers, lending an authenticity to the soundworld of Tubular Bells that even Mike Oldfield himself cannot be bothered to muster these days. However, "cannot be bothered" seemed to be the watchword for this performance. After the precision of the earlier works, this was just plain sloppy, full of obvious mistakes as well as sections (including the final guitar playout) which hadn't even been properly transcribed. The arrogance of Charles Hazelwood as he sneered at the audience for liking this kind of music took the biscuit though. His introduction was full of basic mistakes - he talked about how the music was assembled by Oldfield playing all the instruments (he didn't) with great care (side one was recorded in a week, mostly using the first take of each overdub owing to lack of studio time). He went on to complain about how the finished record sounded too clinical and perfect (really? Oldfield himself complains about the numerous clearly audible glitches, mains hum and sniffs throughout side 1). Mike Oldfield may (most certainly) not represent the height of intellectual rigour within the world of minimalism - playing lip-service to it more as a prevalent style within a rather whimsical Rock Music instrumental. But he was nevertheless responsible for a piece of music the popular imagination to a far greater extent than Charles Hazelwood is ever likely to do on evidence of this performances.

Have to agree about the Tubular Bells performance. All the 1st three pieces were excellent, and I really enjoyed each one. At the back of the QEH they sounded terrific. But Tubular Bells had many sloppy moments (guitar mainly) and sounded somewhat muddy from my seat. And I too was also expecting Part Two - they should've made it clearer in the advertising. Personally, I didn't think that Charles Hazelwood was arrogant, and did his usual excellent job of guiding the audience through the music, especially the less well-known pieces. Maybe his "bell end" joke and the "I hope you found that sensual" comment weren't his best moments though .... But well worth the admission for 3/4 of the concert. Maybe it was for the better they didn't try playing Part Two......

and of course Monsieur Oldfield was deeply inspired by the French band rehearsing in the Virgin studios while he was waiting for studio time - they were Christian Vander's Magma. Listen to Mekanik Destruciw Komandoh and hear where the main Tubercular balls riff started life. (and you really should listen to Magma, minimal it ain't)

Add comment

The future of Arts Journalism

 

You can stop theartsdesk.com closing!

We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £33,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d

And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.

To take a subscription now simply click here.

And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?

newsletter

Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday!

Simply enter your email address in the box below

View previous newsletters