Macbeth, Royal Opera | reviews, news & interviews
Macbeth, Royal Opera
Macbeth, Royal Opera
Stunning soprano and firm conducting salvage this unworthy Verdi staging
Tuesday, 24 May 2011
Liudmyla Monastyrska, a tireless driving force, and Simon Keenlyside as the MacbethsBoth images by Clive Barda
The staging smacks of Covent Garden's familiar Verdi-by-numbers - surprising since it's the often inventive Phyllida Lloyd's concept, revived by Harry Fehr, but it might as well be the inert pageantry of Elijah Moshinsky - while the necessary singing-acting, no doubt as a result, is mostly one-dimensional and overcooked. Verdi's first confident shot at music-theatre, revised for Paris in 1864 but already vivid in outline four years before Rigoletto broke the mould, deserves better. At least it enjoys firm-of-purpose conducting by Antonio Pappano and one vocal performance of unflagging brilliance.
The staging smacks of Covent Garden's familiar Verdi-by-numbers - surprising since it's the often inventive Phyllida Lloyd's concept, revived by Harry Fehr, but it might as well be the inert pageantry of Elijah Moshinsky - while the necessary singing-acting, no doubt as a result, is mostly one-dimensional and overcooked. Verdi's first confident shot at music-theatre, revised for Paris in 1864 but already vivid in outline four years before Rigoletto broke the mould, deserves better. At least it enjoys firm-of-purpose conducting by Antonio Pappano and one vocal performance of unflagging brilliance.
There was no fear or terror in Verdi's great, lightning-flash operatic condensation of "Is this a dagger?"
Explore topics
Share this article
more Opera
Rodelinda, The English Concert, Bicket, Saffron Hall review - perfect team helps us stay the long Handel course
Saffron Hall celebrates its 10th anniversary in the greatest possible style
Gazzaniga's Don Giovanni, Royal College of Music review - a modest one-acter overloaded
Good young singers get more opportunities than the actual work offers
Jephtha, Royal Opera review - uncomfortable sacrifice oratorio not seismic enough
Sobriety and darkness eclipse Handel's dramatic vividness, despite strong performances
theartsdesk at Wexford Festival Opera - four operas and a recital in one crazy day
Youth takes the comedy award in fringe delights alongside a well-done schlocky rarity
theartsdesk in Ukraine - Stankovych's 'Psalms of War' at the Lviv National Opera
A powerful new work written in blood from the inside
Un ballo in maschera, Chelsea Opera Group, Cadogan Hall review - Italianate vitality, if not much finesse
Broad brush strokes, but here was a world-class Verdi heroine in the making
La Rondine, Opera North review - rehabilitation for a Puccini damp squib?
The romantic nostalgia of a world that vanished forever
Masque of Might, Opera North review - a tale of ecological virtue
Pountney plunders Purcell to make the greenest show in a green season
Iolanthe, English National Opera review - still gorgeous but ever so slightly less funny than before
Not all the cast changes are gains in revival of Cal McCrystal's funny and beautiful G&S
Faust, Irish National Opera review - world-class singing turns the musical-dramatic screw
Fabulous principals and some good ideas to elevate Gounod's old-fashioned melodrama
Falstaff, Opera North review - going green and having fun
Verdi’s comic masterpiece with a retro feel of its own
First Person: Director Sir David Pountney on creating a new 'Masque of Might' from the music of Purcell
Launching Opera North’s Green Season with a climate sceptic as villain
Add comment