Manon Lescaut, Opera Holland Park review - attempt to empower commodified woman falls flat | reviews, news & interviews
Manon Lescaut, Opera Holland Park review - attempt to empower commodified woman falls flat
Manon Lescaut, Opera Holland Park review - attempt to empower commodified woman falls flat
Star quality from Elizabeth Llewellyn doesn't quite lift this dramatically inert evening
![](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/mast_image_landscape/public/mastimages/Manon%201.jpeg?itok=oaWWHHL6)
"Waiting is always wearisome," declare the socialites as glitter-and-be-gay Manon Lescaut receives in the home of her nasty old "protector" Geronte. Despite the numerous sugar-plums Puccini weaves into his first fluent operatic masterpiece, waiting is very wearisome in the first half of Karolina Sofulak's new production for Opera Holland Park.
Sofulak gives us neither the 18th-century powder and paint of the Abbé Prévost novel upon which Puccini and the more effete Massenet based their operas nor the "desperate passion" Puccini vowed as his trump card (and succeeded), at least not in the acting. There are only three settings: the 1960s club/bar which makes a poor substitute for the hustle and bustle of a square in Amiens, Geronte's love-nest and an endgame with a brick wall and a lamp-post: no shipping off to America for the fallen woman - probably wouldn't work in the setting - nor death in the desert plain improbably located beyond New Orleans. The cabined and confined crowd in Act 1 get to do some desultory moves as Tim Claydon's choreography injects a bit of belated life into the (in)action, but there's none of the youthful vivacity radiating from the orchestral handling of Puccini's score. Co-ordination wasn't strong on the first night; Robinson tends to keep his head down, most often in the score, and doesn't provide the ideal high beat for the singers. Star quality comes at last with the elegant and slightly sphinx-like presence of Llewellyn's Manon, and a bit of moonshine in her first meeting with Des Grieux; Auty has the right Italianate sound, though the very top is now bottled. His desperation in the later stages is vocally convincing. Paul Carey Jones as Manon's creepy-energetic pimp-brother and Stephen Richardson as big-bucks Geronte (both pictured above with Llewellyn) bring the most to their characterisations.
There is no luxury, nor bling, for the rich man's house, only tatty furniture (OHP never has a big budget for design, but George Johnson-Leigh could have taken a leaf out of Antony McDonald's Ariadne auf Naxos at OHP last year and insisted on a classier dressing-table and bed; it doesn't take much). That elf outfit Manon chooses for couture may be authentically 60s, as far as I know, but it's the one piece of fashion which Llewellyn can't wear well. To have one camp stereotype for the fashion-shoot which substitutes for Manon's dancing lesson is otiose, even if we know that gay men were still forced into those roles in the 1960s; to give us five is enraging. The duet is a physical embarrassment, though vocally good: "come, embrace me, hold me close to your breast," sings Manon, but Auty's Des Grieux seems reluctant to come close (contact at last pictured below). Manon's arrest is lifeless on stage, though Robinson has certainly put the strings through their paces in the focus and fire of the final confusion. With more spotlight on the music, Act 3 fares better: the Intermezzo glows, the ensemble in which nominally the prostitutes are lined up for export packs the biggest punch of the evening. Sofulak has the not bad idea of making them multiple Manons in glittering evening wear: still sold objects humiliated by the bar-room crowd gawking at them. The big feminist statement comes in Act 4. This Manon has simply had enough of men, Des Grieux included - and who wouldn't, since he only whines on about his terrible fate. There are some awkward misalliances between text and staging, but nothing wrong with the idea of Manon removing herself, not dying. It just isn't moving, though Llewellyn is perfectly poised and now in near-vintage voice. The trouble with what Sofulak calls in the programme a "meditation on female empowerment" is that, however you look at it, Puccini's and Prévost's heroine has no power at all. And that in itself can be disturbing. Here, alas, we're left unruffled.
Subscribe to theartsdesk.com
Thank you for continuing to read our work on theartsdesk.com. For unlimited access to every article in its entirety, including our archive of more than 15,000 pieces, we're asking for £5 per month or £40 per year. We feel it's a very good deal, and hope you do too.
To take a subscription now simply click here.
And if you're looking for that extra gift for a friend or family member, why not treat them to a theartsdesk.com gift subscription?
more Opera
![Carmen (Rihab Chaieb) sets her sights on Don José (Evan LeRoy Johnson)](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/Carmen%20Prom%203.jpg?itok=PW7rkthy)
![Lyricism wins over discussion: Sebastian Kohlepp (Flamand), Stephen Marsh (Olivier), Peter Rose (La Roche), conductor Alexander Soddy, Malin Byström (Countess) and Bo Skovhus (Count)](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/Closing%20Concert-%20Capriccio%20%C2%A9%20Andrew%20Perry%2037-medium.jpg?itok=2IIwa-Ti)
![Réka Jónás, Lily de la Haye and Stuart Pendred in The Fabulist - cardinal sinning](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/3B9A2322-Edit.jpg?itok=uDXzVpKZ)
![Penny Sofroniadou, Verity Wingate and Hubert Zapiór in a scene from the Serebrennikov production](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/Verity%20Wingate%2C%20Hubert%20Zapi%C3%B3r%20and%20in%20The%20Marriage%20of%20Figaro%20%C2%A9%20Jess%20Shurte%20051-medium.jpg?itok=BmjjQmvz)
![Shengzhi Ren as Oedipus](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/Shengzhi%20Ren%20as%20Oedipus%20in%20Oedipus%20Rex%2C%20Edinburgh%20International%20Festival_%C2%A9JessShurte_015-medium.jpg?itok=TSnmHS1w)
![Not strictly ballroom: Les Jardin du Voix and Compagnie Käfig in The Fairy Queen](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/fq%20gen%202.jpg?itok=N2vla84-)
![Stuart Skelton as Tristan and Miina-Liisa Värelä as Isolde in Act 3](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/Tristan%201.jpeg?itok=pnFGMENJ)
![The maestro composes: Constantine Akritides as Puccini](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/Web-TheButterflyHouse-Credit-SteveGregson-132%20%281200x800%29.jpg?itok=vm22KyxW)
![Smoke signals: Clare Presland in 'Il Segreto di Susanna'](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/ss%20sus%20fag_0.jpg?itok=Hmrn-W8p)
![Lucia Lucas outside The Dream Tent in Birmingham](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/AF_053_New_Year_Cast_%26_Rehearsal_BOC.jpg?itok=AZ21jes9)
![Stirring stuff: Roman Arndt as Ernani, with chorus, in Buxton International Festival’s production of the opera](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/Roman%20Arndt%20as%20Ernani%20centre%20with%20chorus%20%282%29%20%281200x801%29_0.jpg?itok=-d-p2F-d)
![Katharina Kastening: 'the underlying message regarding the danger in female stereotyping is one that unfortunately persists in our societies'](https://theartsdesk.com/sites/default/files/styles/thumbnail/public/mastimages/Carmen%201.jpeg?itok=Dat42NmJ)
Add comment