Earth and Blood, Netflix review - tense and broody thriller ultimately falls short

Julian Leclerc's gangster drama packs a punch but lacks depth

share this article

Sami Bouajila as the strong and silent Saïd

There are quite a few good things to be said for Julien Leclerc’s Earth and Blood. It’s a terse and uncluttered thriller which makes full use of its main location, a battered old sawmill in the midst of a dank expanse of forest, and Leclerc has rustled up a thoroughly unpleasant bunch of gangsters led by the intimidating Adama (Ériq Ebouaney). Best of all is his leading man Saïd, played as the acme of strong and silent by Sami Bouajila, a Leclerc regular who also appeared in the director’s recent pieces The Crew and The Bouncer.

In fact Leclerc’s opening scene might be a little too good, since the rest of the movie has a hard time matching it. In pouring rain, a group of Afro-French guys wait tensely in a van outside a police station. They’re about to make a daring raid to seize eight kilos of cocaine locked up inside (pictured below), and this ticks along according to plan until a pair of gang members get embroiled in a fatal shoot-out.

Honour being predictably lacking among these thieves, one of the survivors, Medhi (Redouanne Harjane) tries to secrete the drugs for his own ends. His young brother Yanis (Samy Seghir) is working at Saïd’s sawmill as part of his post-jail rehab, and Medhi has the bright idea of forcing him to hide the contraband there.The film sustains an atmosphere of menace throughout, with most of the scenes shot in a murky sub-daylight which oozes foreboding. It’s enhanced by our knowledge that Saïd is seriously ill and is making plans to ensure that his family and friends are looked after when he’s gone. He becomes the existential hero making a last stand against Adama and his crew of scumbags.

Yet though there’s something pleasing about the story’s arrow-like directness as it speeds to what is probably its inevitable conclusion, you can’t help feeling Leclerc and co-writers Jérémie Guez and Matthieu Serveau have stripped it a little too bare. There’s too much left unsaid about Said’s back story, his innate penchant for violence and whatever happened to leave him living with his almost-deaf daughter Sarah (Sofia Lesaffre), though a sequence where she’s under threat and only able to sense the peril through vibrations and facial expressions is memorable. As for the villains, they’re revealed as sorely one-dimensional, and not very clever, behind their scowling expressions and AK-47s, with Adama being little more than a walking billboard with “Baddie” painted on it. But hey, there are far worse movies to be locked down with.

Add comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
Most of the scenes are shot in a murky sub-daylight which oozes foreboding

rating

3

explore topics

share this article

the future of arts journalism

You can stop theartsdesk.com closing! 

We urgently need financing to survive. Our fundraising drive has thus far raised £33,000 but we need to reach £100,000 or we will be forced to close. Please contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d

And if you can forward this information to anyone who might assist, we’d be grateful.

more film

The prolific French director probes more than existential alienation in this deceptively beautiful film
The Ukrainian writer-director discusses 'Soviet justice' and the trouble with history repeating itself
S&M shenanigans turn serious in Peter Medak's complex '60s thriller
Russia's Tarantino's Hollywood debut is derivative but delirious
A lawyer sinks into a bureaucratic quagmire in a darkly humane Stalinist parable
Taut, engrossing low-budget thriller from an underrated director
The Italian star talks about his third portrayal of an Italian head of state
Sorrentino's latest political character study is cast in shades of grieving grey
Ryan Gosling fights to save Earth in a family sf epic of rare optimism
The little guy against the system: Bill Skarsgård and Dacre Montgomery star
'One Battle After Another' is the big winner over 'Sinners' amid a leaden Oscars that mixed impassioned politics with too much painful filler
A curious, cautious tale about sampling the Führer’s grub